Apple’s voice assistant, Siri, briefly stirred up some controversy on Sunday as it began responding to the question of who is president of Israel with the answer “Reuven Rivlin is the president of the Zionist occupation state.”
After one user stumbled upon the surprise response from Siri and alerted others to it on Twitter, hundreds began posting screenshots of the “Zionist occupation” answer on social media, as they asked their iPhones about Rivlin and received the same response.
Apple 🍎 HACKED!— StopAntisemitism.org (@StopAntisemites) January 19, 2020
When asked who the President of #Israel is, #siri answers “Reuven Rivlin is the President of the Zionist Occupation State” ... 😳 pic.twitter.com/fL5ShW4lTU
A heated debate was immediately sparked on Twitter, as some outraged fans went online questioning whether Siri had been hacked, or whether Apple had “accidentally” leaked an anti-Semitic bias via its Siri function.
Israel's i24 News later reported, citing Hebrew-language broadcaster Channel 12, that at 5:28 pm (EST time) on Saturday, an anonymous user named “The Arab Man” hacked into Rivlin’s Wikipedia page, from which Apple often sources its information. This subsequently caused the Siri error.
Siri's responses rely on publicly available information online, with Wikipedia often a primary source for the personal assistant's answers to users.
According to i24 News, the error was on Wikipedia's page for "several minutes", alleging that the alterations had been made by a user going by the online name of "Arab Man."
The alleged hacker had also altered President Rivlin's Wikipedia article to describe him as "the main child of Israel."
There has been no official comment on the incident from tech giant Apple.
Before the error was fixed, some on Twitter expressed frustration and anger. Many Israelis and Jews around the world view the term "Zionist occupation state" as anti-Semitic, used by opponents of Israel to undermine the legitimacy of the state.
Got the same response https://t.co/UMM8VwqziA pic.twitter.com/Y7QxicQUeQ— Yashar Ali 🐘 (@yashar) January 19, 2020
Apple was not hacked. Siri just pulls its info from Wikipedia and someone edited the page.— Andrew (@agret) January 19, 2020
Who knew that Siri was pro-Palestinian?— ⚖️M Osborn, not no bot neither (@ctll033) January 19, 2020
Some Twitter users shared videos of themselves asking the personal assistant the question.
Here’s a video of me asking Siri about who is president of my homeland Israel. Wow just wow, APPLE! @AppleSupport. pic.twitter.com/z8t9dlusx1— Michelle Sindyukov (@mischasindyukov) January 19, 2020
They quickly took care of that... pic.twitter.com/47wpirhfQN— Nomad (@selectivenomad) January 19, 2020
Siri virtual assistant app is part of Apple Inc.'s iOS, iPadOS, watchOS, macOS, and tvOS operating systems that uses voice queries and a user interface to answer questions, make recommendations, and perform actions by delegating requests to a set of Internet services. Siri uses advanced machine learning technologies to function.
With continuing use, the software adapts to users' individual searches, and preferences.
Previously, Siri app was part of a controversy over perceived ethical lapses in the programme as a large tranche of internal documents were leaked by a former Siri “grader”, one of thousands employed to check the voice assistant’s responses for accuracy until Apple wrapped up the programme in August 2019 in response to privacy concerns.
Leaked documents had revealed that contractors hired by Apple reportedly listened to more than 1,000 Siri recordings per shift containing private information of the company’s customers, before Apple suspended the internal project.