08:24 GMT27 January 2021
Listen Live
    Military & Intelligence
    Get short URL

    Peace is hanging in the balance in the South China Sea region, Michael Auslin noted, presenting three possible real-world scenarios under which Washington and Beijing may draw themselves into a direct conflict.

    Although Beijing has not set yet a formal air defense identification zone (ADIZ) over the South China Sea, it has obviously laid down a "redline" in the region, noted Michael Auslin, a resident scholar and the director of Japan Studies at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), adding that the peace is hanging in the balance in this part of the Asia Pacific region.

    "The Obama Administration apparently having decided to challenge China's claims, the US and China are now potentially closer to an armed encounter than at any time in the past 20 years," the scholar underscored depicting three scenarios of a potential conflict.

    According to Michael Auslin, an "accident" is one of the possible scenarios. The US Navy is purportedly considering sending its vessels within 12 miles of China's manmade islands in the South China Sea, the expert elaborated, and so far entering into China's "sovereign territory." The US move may result in a collision with a Chinese maritime patrol, "with each side responding in turn."

    The expert does not exclude the possibility of a mid-air collision between Chinese and US fighters over the sea, such as happened in 2001, when a US Navy plane collided with a Chinese fighter jet. An accident could lead to a stand-off, the scholar emphasized.

    Dubbing another possible scenario "premeditation," Mr. Auslin stressed that China may also decide "that stopping American incursion into their newly claimed waters early on is the best opportunity to make the risks to Washington seem too high."


    Do you think the US actions in the South China Sea are provocative?
    • No. They are entirely appropriate given China’s increasingly assertive claims
      12.0% (369)
    • Yes. Such actions are irresponsible, dangerous and detrimental to regional peace and stability
      68.6% (2102)
    • Both countries are acting provocative turning the South China Sea into a region of great power competition
      19.4% (594)
    Voted: 3066
    The scholar suggested that China's military forces may launch an operation in order to prevent US planes from flying in "restricted" skies, at the same time "leaving the US to decide how far to respond." Such a move would have sparked a confrontation, despite the fact Obama is currently bogged down in the Middle East and Ukraine.

    According to Auslin's third scenario, an "indirect conflict," Beijing may decide to stop ships and planes of America's regional allies and escort them out of the skies above China's manmade islands. Such a move may trigger chain reaction, the scholar emphasized, claiming that a direct clash between China and any of its neighbors will inevitably result in Washington's involvement in the conflict.

    "With no de-escalation mechanisms, and deep distrust on both sides, the more capable China becomes in defending its claimed territory, the more risks the US will face in challenging those claims," warned the scholar.

    "That may not ensure that there will be a military encounter, but it steadily raises the chances of one," he concluded.


    Russia, China Air Military Influence to Exceed US in Future
    China Maps Out 'Active Defense' Military Strategy Aimed Against Hegemonism
    Chinese Navy Demands US Spy Planes Leave Disputed South China Sea Islands
    China Expects to Continue Military Cooperation With US - Defense Ministry
    Middle East, NATO, disputed waters, islands, conflict, The US Navy, South China Sea, China, Washington, US, Ukraine, Beijing
    Community standardsDiscussion