The words 'President Puigdemont' have been banned from Catalan public media, on the grounds that they defy the principle of informational neutrality. Sputnik spoke to Josep Costa, professor of Political Theory at the University of Pompeu Fabra, about what’s happening in Catalonia as the election draws closer.
Sputnik: What kind of censorship has been seen by Catalan media platforms since the application of Article 155?
Josep Costa: There was an idea that the central government might take over the control of the Catalan public media. In the end, they did not decide to exclusively take over, and as far as private media is concerned, nothing has changed. The only real thing is this sort of 'extreme control' that government-owned radio and TV are being subject to from the opposition, the pro-Spanish groups that are using the electoral petition to tell people what to do.
They seem to be particularly concerned about the coverage of the former ministers, the government, and the president who were sacked, and forced out of office through article 155. They have been trying to reduce coverage of this in the public media, or at least to change the narrative of that coverage.
Sputnik: They have now banned the words 'President Puigdemont', as he is no longer president. Do you consider this to be censorship?
Josep Costa: On the banning of the phrase 'President Puigdemont', there is something peculiar about this, as Catalan presidents are referred to as such even after they have left office. Whether he is the president now or not, he is entitled to be called 'the president', or 'President Puigdemont', as former presidents are referred to in the same way. There's a lack of consideration here for the Catalan public culture, because to refer to former presidents under the name 'President', is a common tradition that happens in other countries as well.
Sputnik: What about the petition released asking for the color 'yellow' to be banned from the electoral campaign?
Josep Costa: It’s the electoral commission on a petition by the socialist party, making a decision that the members of the polling stations, those acting in an official capacity in the polling stations should not be allowed to wear the yellow symbols used to demand the release of the political prisoners. Also, they've issued a similar decision on public buildings, or even in monuments, that the yellow color that was symbolic of the campaign of the release of the political prisoners that all of this should be removed. Anything related to the campaign for the release of the prisoners should be banned from public premises, and voting premises, as well as polling stations. It has caused a lot of outrage.
Sputnik: Is there anything that you feel that international media is failing to report on?
Josep Costa: People feel that this is a really crucial election. The turn-out will be huge and the stakes are very high. There is a lot of questioning as to whether this will be a free and fair election because the Spanish government, and media are not abiding by the rules of neutrality and impartiality. There seems to be a media storm, or government push, for a vote against independence, or for pro-independence parties. The stakes are so high it will not be a fair and balanced coverage of the election by the media. I don't know to what extent that is apparent to everyone, they tend to focus on the Catalan media as biased, in favor of independence. We need to take into consideration, however, that the Catalan public media enjoy a very limited share of the audience. The vast majority of media that is watched or listened to in Catalonia, is Spanish media, and they are pushing very hard against independence. We sort of fear that it is not a balanced field ahead of the election.
The fact of registration and authorization of users on Sputnik websites via users’ account or accounts on social networks indicates acceptance of these rules.
Users are obliged abide by national and international laws. Users are obliged to speak respectfully to the other participants in the discussion, readers and individuals referenced in the posts.
The websites’ administration has the right to delete comments made in languages other than the language of the majority of the websites’ content.
In all language versions of the sputniknews.com websites any comments posted can be edited.
A user comment will be deleted if it:
does not correspond with the subject of the post;
promotes hatred and discrimination on racial, ethnic, sexual, religious or social basis or violates the rights of minorities;
violates the rights of minors, causing them harm in any form, including moral damage;
contains ideas of extremist nature or calls for other illegal activities;
contains insults, threats to other users, individuals or specific organizations, denigrates dignity or undermines business reputations;
contains insults or messages expressing disrespect to Sputnik;
violates privacy, distributes personal data of third parties without their consent or violates privacy of correspondence;
describes or references scenes of violence, cruelty to animals;
contains information about methods of suicide, incites to commit suicide;
pursues commercial objectives, contains improper advertising, unlawful political advertisement or links to other online resources containing such information;
promotes products or services of third parties without proper authorization;
contains offensive language or profanity and its derivatives, as well as hints of the use of lexical items falling within this definition;
contains spam, advertises spamming, mass mailing services and promotes get-rich-quick schemes;
promotes the use of narcotic / psychotropic substances, provides information on their production and use;
contains links to viruses and malicious software;
is part of an organized action involving large volumes of comments with identical or similar content ("flash mob");
“floods” the discussion thread with a large number of incoherent or irrelevant messages;
violates etiquette, exhibiting any form of aggressive, humiliating or abusive behavior ("trolling");
doesn’t follow standard rules of the English language, for example, is typed fully or mostly in capital letters or isn’t broken down into sentences.
The administration has the right to block a user’s access to the page or delete a user’s account without notice if the user is in violation of these rules or if behavior indicating said violation is detected.