05:25 GMT +322 September 2019
Listen Live
    A general view shows the reactor building at the Bushehr nuclear power plant in southern Iran, 1200 kms south of Tehran, on August 20, 2010

    Why Trump Hostility on Nuclear Deal Empowers Reactionaries in Iran

    © AFP 2019 / ATTA KENARE
    Opinion
    Get short URL
    203
    Subscribe

    By criticizing the nuclear accord with Iran Trump is trying to get new concessions from Tehran, however, experts believe that it could result in mounting tensions in the Middle East since renegotiation of the deal is likely to disturb the political balance in Iran.

    WASHINGTON (Sputnik) — President Donald Trump’s stubborn diplomatic pressure on Tehran to renegotiate the nuclear deal is only empowering reactionary elements inside Iran and disrupting the country’s ideological balance, analysts told Sputnik.

    Trump, in his first speech to the UN General Assembly last week, called the 2015 nuclear accord, known as the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), an "embarrassment" and one of the worst deals the United States had ever entered.

    And on September 20, US Ambassador to the UN Nikki Haley told ABC's "Good Morning America" that Trump firmly believes Iran was violating the accord by carrying out ballistic missile testing and providing support to terrorists.

    Iran's Reactionaries

    US Academics for Peace Executive Director and Conscience International President James Jennings told Sputnik that Trump did not appear to anticipate the possible responses his hostile moves would promote in Tehran.

    "There is a narrow field of action, but Iran refuses to be pushed around," he said. "The Rouhani government can only retreat so far before energizing the conservative bloc, which would upset whatever balance exists in Tehran at the moment."

    Trump most likely was not seeking to deliberately provoke a full-scale war with Iran but imagined that his threats and bluster would force the Tehran government to agree to renegotiate the 2015 agreement, Jennings explained.

    "It is part of Trump´s technique. He is merely following the method laid out in his book, ‘The Art of the Deal.’ He is most likely trying to get new concessions from Iran, which would please Israel and give him a prestigious ‘win,’" he said.

    However, even the leadership of the US armed forces opposed Trump’s efforts to scrap the 2015 agreement.

    "The Pentagon will resist changing it [the nuclear accord] at this point because it would complicate their mission. There is no clear violation, even if it is claimed by [Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin] Netanyahu`s minions in the Congress," he said.

    Iran could respond to Trump’s efforts to scrap the accord by using its influence to stir up unrest at different key places across the Middle East forcing the United States to further commit its already over-stretched armed forces, Jennings predicted.

    The best hope of moderating Trump’s determination to confront Tehran lay in the possible moderating influence of the former senior military officers that he had surrounded himself with, Jennings suggested.

    White House Rivalry

    Author and historian Reese Erlich told Sputnik that while there was serious debate in the Trump administration about how to deal with Iran, all the different competing factions agreed in their determination to destroy the 2015 accord.

    "There is fierce debate within the Trump administration on how to tactically respond to the nuclear accord. All factions oppose the accord, but some want to decertify US participation and openly abrogate the agreement," he pointed out.

    Even relative moderates in the administration were determined to intensify economic and international pressure on Iran, Reese cautioned.

    "Others want to formally accept the agreement while undercutting it by passing new sanctions and pressuring international corporations not to invest in Iran," Erlich said. Either option is a serious violation of both US and international law and a blow to peace efforts in the region."

    In July 2015, Iran, the European Union and the so-called P5+1 group of nations – the United States, the United Kingdom, Russia, China, France and Iran – signed the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Actions (JCPOA), which envisions gradual lifting of nuclear-related sanctions imposed on Tehran in exchange for assurances that its nuclear program would remain peaceful.

    The views and opinions expressed in the article do not necessarily reflect those of Sputnik.

    Related:

    Tillerson Admits IAEA Reports Indicate Iran in Compliance With Nuclear Deal
    EU Foreign Policy Chief Sees ‘No Need’ to Renegotiate Iran Nuclear Agreement
    Iranian President Speaks About US Possible Withdrawal Nuclear Deal
    Iran Does Not Live Up to Terms of Nuclear Agreement - Saudi Arabia
    Trump on Iran Nuclear Deal's Future: 'I Have Decided'
    Iran 'Clearly in Default of Expectations' of Nuclear Deal - Tillerson
    Nuclear Nonproliferation Experts Urge Trump Not to Abandon Iran Nuclear Deal
    Tags:
    nuclear agreement, Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), Donald Trump, Iran, United States
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik