13:31 GMT +305 December 2016
Live
    Women in burka

    ‘Security’ Issue: Debate Over Burqa Ban Moves to Quebec

    © AFP 2016/ SHAH MARAI
    US
    Get short URL
    626221

    Already banned in public spaces in France and ten other European nations, the burqa is now at risk of being banned in Québec, as well.

    Justice Minister Stephanie Vallée of the Québec Liberal Party, who announced the bill on Tuesday, stated that the ban is necessary for “security, identification and communication purposes.”

    Vallée claims that the assembly did not intend to target a specific clothing article or religion, and repeatedly pointed to the religious neutrality of Québec law.

    If passed, however, the law would stop women who wear veils from receiving government benefits, as it will make it illegal to give or receive government services if a person’s face is covered.

    “The bill is seen as a more moderate version of the former Parti Québécois government’s derided ‘charter of values,’ which had set out to ban turbans, kippas, head scarves and other religious displays among Quebec’s civil servants,” the Globe and Mail reports. It marks the Québec parliament’s third bill aimed at legislating secularism in public since 2010.

    The bill will allow for religious exemptions, provided they are consistent with the equality of men and women, and other set standards applied by parliament.

    Jean-François Lisée, the new leader of the PQ, ran his campaign heavily on the banning of the burqa. Asked during a Monday radio interview if he would consider a ban similar to that in France, where police can actually stop a woman and fine her for wearing the covering in public, he stated that it is a possibility.

    “It is very targeted,” Mihad Fahmy, a lawyer with the National Council of Canadian Muslims told the Guardian. “Given the body of case law that already exists across the country and even the different human rights codes, one has to wonder why Quebec felt a need to address specifically in a piece of legislation the issue of face coverings.”

    The burqa has long been a controversial issue, and many argue over whether it is a symbol of female oppression.

    On one hand, some rights groups argue that women wearing a veil are not exercising freedom, as the burqa is viewed as a symbol of subjugation. They point to nations where women are sometimes beaten, stoned, or killed for removing a covering which prevents them being seen or heard. These groups and individuals frequently point to the women who fought against a woman’s right to vote in the US, claiming that a woman should be fine with the husband voting for the entire household. They claim to be fighting for Islamic women to have agency over their own lives.

    On the other hand, other groups, who likewise label themselves women’s rights groups, insist that it is an individual’s right to make the decision for themselves, and that for the government or any non-Muslim to claim to know what is best for the individual is oppressive, racist and Islamophobic. They argue that the West criticizing burqas is a distraction from the sexism in their own society, claiming, essentially, that people who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones.

    Related:

    Change of Tune: Norwegian 'Hardliner' Immigration Minister Opposes Burka Ban
    Majority of UK Residents Support Burka Ban - Poll
    Majority of Swiss Support the Burka Ban
    Fashion Police: Swedish Cops Back Burka Ban
    Danish Party Calls to Defy Int'l Law and Impose Burka Ban
    Tags:
    Muslim, Islamaphobia, Burqa, Quebec Parliament, Liberal Party, Jean-François Lisée, Stephanie Vallée, Canada, Québec
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik
    • Сomment

    All comments

    • Atheo
      I have been there in the winter and most everyone wore face masks just to prevent frostbite.
    • revsuzanne
      Remember a little while back... some British soldiers snuck into an ISIS camp in burqas... and managed to carry in enough weapons and ammo take out the entire position. Yeah... that can be used both ways.
      Forget about this crap where they want to cover their faces to get a drivers license.
    Show new comments (0)

    Top stories