13:31 GMT +323 March 2017
Live
    A Russian matryoshka doll with an image of US presidential candidate Donald Trump at a gift shop

    How Trump May Have Just Caused Russia to Fall Back in Love with the USA

    © Sputnik/ Anton Denisov
    Politics
    Get short URL
    162325324

    Reflecting on the prospects for the coming year, Rossiya Segodyna political commentator Dmitri Kosyrev recalls Russia's ever-changing attitudes toward the United States over the past three decades. For most Russians, he says, Trump's election shows that the American people are not hell-bent on hysterical Russophobia. But it's not all so simple.

    In a punchy op-ed for RIA Novosti, Kosyrev explained that for Russians, "the coming year is set to be a strange one," filled with psychological shocks. Two months ago, the pundit recalled, Russians learned that the US is not filled to the brim with Russophobic propagandists and those who would believe their propaganda. "It turns out that they also have normal people. Moreover, there are a lot of them – enough for them to gather their strength and elect a president. What kind of president he will be is still unclear, but at least one thing is obvious – at least he resembles a human being."

    Russians, the Kosyrev suggested, "still haven't fully grasped the significance of this discovery. And we haven't thought about what we should do now – how we should think of America – should we come to fall in love with it?"

    Last month, the commentator noted, a tearful Australian woman named Lisa Pryor published an op-ed in the New York Times titled 'Dear America, Why Did You Let Us Down?' "The woman complained that since Trump's victory, she cries in the bath, cries in her car, etc. – cries because 'the conventions that define liberal Western democracy are stripped away by Donald J. Trump, with every distressful appointment, each impulsive outburst.'"

    Pryor appealed to Americans, asked them what they had done with their country. After all, she said, America, which once "gave us a poetry of democracy that was grand and uplifting," was in freefall. "Roads, airports, an economy, perhaps even a society, falling to pieces." Trump's election, she said, "feels like a sudden plunge" after a gradual decline.

    Below that, Kosyrev noted, "there is an appeal from the editors for non-Americans tell NYT how Trump's election has changed their attitudes toward America (if it has changed them)." "A good question deserves a good answer," the pundit said, "even if it's not necessary for it to be in the New York Times." 

    On the other side of the world from Australia, there was Russia, and Russians, for the most part, reacted to Trump's victory very differently. Most hoped the President-elect would lead to a fresh start for Russian-US relations, or at least reduce the level of tensions between the two countries. Kosyrev's take of things is a bit more complex, and subtle.

    "But where are we to go from here in our attitudes toward the US?" Kosyrev asked. "Back to the 1960s?"

    "Back then," he recalled, "there was not so much love toward the US as there was a growing sense of envy, admiration, and an inferiority complex. Soviet propaganda at its best tried to change things, but caused the opposite reaction. The more it tried to convince us that we faced a crumbling society being torn apart by its contradictions, the more Soviet people began reflecting and making their own conclusions."

    Moscow hipsters (Stilyagi) dancing the twist in the late 1950s.
    © Sputnik/ Valeriy Shustov
    Moscow hipsters (Stilyagi) dancing the twist in the late 1950s.

    "For some, the beacon of light was Europe. To others, it was America. Basically, this was a beacon that shone on the other side of the Iron Curtain, where one had to have the appropriate CV to go and visit." After all, it was feared, "one might go and look, and not come back."

    "This envious admiration lasted about to the end of the 1980s," the commentator noted, "when the Iron Curtain began to crumble, and Russians went 'over there' to take a look, or get a job. We had a look, and then the wave began to turn in the opposite direction." 

    People queuing for the McDonald's restaurant in Moscow's central Pushkin Square. The restaurant opened on January 31, 1990
    © Sputnik/ Vladimir Vyatkin
    People queuing for the McDonald's restaurant in Moscow's central Pushkin Square. The restaurant opened on January 31, 1990

    "It's difficult to say when this change in Russian sentiment became irreversible, either quantitatively (i.e. for the majority of the population) or qualitatively (i.e. no more illusions). Probably, it was in 1999, following the US bombing of Yugoslavia, after which pro-Western forces and parties no longer had any chances to win any elections in Russia. Today, they don't have a chance to even get a seat in parliament."

    And after that, Kosyrev recalled, things only got worse: "war and lies, more war and lies, and so on and so forth until the end of 2016, when things came to a head, and united virtually the whole country [Russia that is] in enmity toward the US. No, not enmity – but worse: a sense of utter bewilderment over the nonsense that was being peddled, all without blinking. But also contempt (liars are always treated with contempt). And even a sense of pity."

    A US soldier looks through a pair of binoculars as a fire in the Rumeila oil field burns in the background in southern of Iraq, Sunday, March. 30, 2003
    © AP Photo/ Yonhap/ Jin Sung-chul
    A US soldier looks through a pair of binoculars as a fire in the Rumeila oil field burns in the background in southern of Iraq, Sunday, March. 30, 2003

    "And then Donald Trump appeared, and everything started spinning" in people's perceptions, the analyst noted. "It turned out that we had completely lost contact not with America as a whole, but only with about half of the country. What is to be done? How are they to be hated (or despised) now? Human beings are inert – their thinking is reformed very slowly. Sometimes entire generations come and go, convinced in the rightness of thinking from an earlier era. Change is a painful process."

    "For me, it's been easier," the political writer admitted. "Living one floor below me in my apartment building is my American friend Karl Hutchinson. He ran away from America (from his ex-wife, a feminist, who bankrupted him during their divorce). He met a beautiful Chinese woman. He and I occasionally meet for a drink of - let's say tea. And right now we are both celebrating."

    "We're celebrating because Karl is an archetypal Republican – a native of New Mexico (which is like a second Texas). The Southwestern United States is inhabited by two meter tall men who behave like gentlemen, and they are [what Russians would call] normal in many respects, aside from their accents. For the first time in many years, Karl went to the US Embassy in Moscow to vote for Trump, not believing that anything would come of it. To put it shortly, I always knew that there was 'another America'. With them things can be difficult, but at least a common language exists. These are real people."

    President elect Donald Trump greets members of his family after giving an his acceptance speech at an election night rally, Wednesday, Nov. 9, 2016, in New York.
    © AP Photo/ Julie Jacobson
    President elect Donald Trump greets members of his family after giving an his acceptance speech at an election night rally, Wednesday, Nov. 9, 2016, in New York.

    Kosyrev continues. "Now, we sit together with Karl and sort things out: 'Dmitri,' he says, 'do you think things will Trump will be easy? That remains to be seen. You'd be better off acting honestly and openly with him.' 'Karl', I respond, 'do you know that attempts at perestroika [restructuring] and overhauls in a relationship can be a dangerous thing? But at least now we have a chance.' 'Dmitri,' he asks, 'do you want to see America become great again?'"

    "And here I grow pensive. 'Great how?' I ask. 'What do you mean? Like when you developed Operation Dropshot (the plan for the nuclear bombing of Soviet cities immediately after the Second World War)? Or like in the 1920s, when jazz music was all the rage and the US had no problems with the Soviet Union? Or perhaps there is no point in searching for something in the past, and we need to think of something for a new future.'" 

    Indeed, Kosyrev stressed, "we will now have to create a future. Ignoring America under George W. Bush and Barack Obama was all well and good. Finding out that we could live without them was a comforting thought. Now, everything is more difficult. For a quarter-century, our level of disdain grew incrementally, up to contempt and disregard. Suddenly, we face a new era."

    "Returning to the New York Times editors' appeal – to explain how my attitude toward the US has changed after the advent of Trump: it's simple. America suddenly demonstrated that it was possible to respect it, or if not all of it, then at least half of it. And even to empathize with it a little. Yes, and to cautiously hope for it to succeed."  

    Related:

    What to Expect From 2017, From Syria to Removal of Anti-Russian Sanctions
    Happy New Year, America! The Message of Putin's Response to New US Sanctions
    Trump Bold Enough to Destroy 'Taboos', Revive US-Russian Relations
    Trump Poised to Nullify Obama's Executive Orders, Turn to Russia, Distance China
    Trump Team Eyeing Dana Rohrabacher, Thomas Graham for US Ambassador to Russia
    Trump Seeks to Repeat Kissinger’s Balance of Power Strategy With Russia
    Trump Receives 'Very Nice' Letter From Putin: 'His Thoughts Are So Correct'
    Tags:
    reflection, observations, friendship, op-ed, cooperation, Donald Trump, George W. Bush, Barack Obama, United States, Russia
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik
    • Сomment

    All comments

    • avatar
      copius
      No one is stupid to fall in love with ugly America which has degenerated in the past 16 yrs.
      Let's see how deep into the shit hole USA will go and if Trump can save it.
    • Angus Gallagher
      It's a good article and it mixes realism with hope.
      In the EU, in Britain, in the USA- as anti-globalists and sovereign democrats we think in a completely different way from the usual Left-Right establishment.
      Yet we're besieged on all sides with censorship, McCarthyite purges, the media, and worst of all the neocon-liberal bipartisan cartels all ready to crush Brexit, the FN, even the Trump Presidency.
      So we've come a huge distance in just 6 months but it's not enough to secure a truly watertight peace with Russia as evil and corrupt hands are trying to unpick everything. It's up to President Trump and his cabinet team to reach a lasting settlement with Russia for the benefit of humanity and the redemption of our civilization.
    • avatar
      tobi.gelandoin reply toAngus Gallagher(Show commentHide comment)
      Angus Gallagher,
      The article is good and give hope !!! but your comments are very good !!!
    • avatar
      slimyfox
      Cold war, yes I remember it well as I was born 64 years ago and I was a law student at the nick of it. I remember our and their propaganda and I was living under the impression that we in the west are blessed by our system, by our freedom of movement, and it is true that it mattered a lot to us who were better off than wast majority of our compatriots in so called W. Germany, let alone people in Eastern Germany (DDR).

      We lived under the illusion that our system of exploitation of economically weaker is natural, is just, that only us privileged are something important. Our propaganda filled people with lies promising that everyone can and will succeed only if it wants. That was and is still the biggest lie on the planet as out of tens of millions of population just handful are the lucky one and nothing more, however we grew up in hate of Communism (actually it was socialism as communism is just ideology not a system) as religious hate Satan. We feared it and despised anything related or connected to it and why?

      Because in socialism, they had free schools, free health care, free medicines, free retirement homes for alone people, they did not have people living under the bridges, quite no unemployment, basically their social life and structure was something beyond our system was unable and is still not able to offer. There was no inequality by sex as it is still normal in our systems, women have had 2 – 3 years fully paid maternity leave, women with children worked few years shorter for full retirement age, free kindergartens, and so on. Even today as a relict from the past times in Russia women have 3 years fully paid maternity leave after delivery, 45% women had and still has university degree or more. We still remember 90's how our well paid but badly educated and stupid manual workers searched for highly educated beautiful Eastern (Ukrainian mostly) women who wanted to escape sudden poverty imbecile and psychopath Boris Yeltsin brought to Russia.

      We had to destroy socialism as it was giving bad example to our stupid manual workers who firmly believed that one day they will just awake and become millionaires. We had to keep that myth in order to preserve our privileges, and in this we were not alone, USA with its all mighty Hollywood propaganda machine presenting shining and brilliantly blinding life (bullshit) in USA, and just by such non destructive things USA changed the world as everyone wants better life and everyone wanted better for himself and everyone believed that Hollywood is reality not a factory of dreams.

      In early 70' I visited Yugoslavia which h was Socialist country but not a part of Russian dominance but was rather founder and world leader of non-aligned countries. However it was a socialist country and as I had a girlfriend who was from nowadays Slovenia (back then it was one of Yugoslav Republics) and she studied in Germany in Frankfurt where we met, I visited Yugoslavia many times and spent some most beautiful time in my student days there. That gave me first hand opportunity to meet with students from socialist country and to realise that we have being victims of massive anti socialist propaganda, just because our privileged classes controlled media and political sphere. We had to blacken them, we had to destroy them if we wanted to keep our ordinary people in bubble of bullshit luring them with false hopes.

      Imagine that I as very young have been told that we are living in huge house and having 6 cars Mercedes and Porsche in the garage only because we are working very hard and other not. We owned a lot and workers nothing, we had responsibility and workers not, we had huge costs for living and workers not, and so on and so forth. That was and still is the system of justification of the social differences, that is why Soviet Union as well as all other socialist countries cannot prosper, that is why we have to sanction, isolate a and strangle them until they die and then we resurrect poverty and inequality as happened with Russia after collapse of USSR.

      This fear from Russia and anything Russian is already genetic and it will require several generations before it dissolves, until then our neocon governments will fight Russia as much as they can.
    • Angus Gallagherin reply totobi.gelando(Show commentHide comment)
      tobi.gelando, thank you so much! I do enjoy reading your comments too.
      All the best, Tobi.
    • avatar
      michael
      I think that kosyrev should reconsider his line about Russia falling in love with the us. Distasteful is one way of putting it. International relations and perceptions are not based on the projections of commentators. I believe that most of the Russian people would be more mature than to 'fall in love' with a country / government / people. Rather, to be open to what is offered, whilst remembering how things can be manipulated. Does he read or listen to the domestic programmes regarding the actions of the us in recent history? Does he walk the streets and talk with various people about how they see the usg and its actions? From his statement, I think not.
    • avatar
      hopscotch64
      Trump has not been sworn in yet. Something the author seems to have forgotten. What Trump says and does is never, never the same. I really hate to see the grave disappointment many people are going to have when Trump actually becomes president.
    Show new comments (0)