A coroner has called for the British government to review so-called “smart motorways” after two men were killed by a truck on the M1 in South Yorkshire in 2019.
Coroner David Urpeth said smart motorways possessed "an ongoing risk of future deaths".
The wife of Jason Mercer - one of those who died - tells us she “broke down” when she heard the coroner’s findings.— Hallam FM News (@hallamfmnews) January 18, 2021
Claire Mercer’s been campaigning to get smart motorways scrapped since her husband’s death@MotorwaysKill pic.twitter.com/tqn5ozIvM7
He recorded a verdict of unlawful killing on Jason Mercer, 44, and Alexandru Murgeanu, 22, and said he would be writing to Highways England and Transport Secretary Grant Shapps.
On traditional UK motorways there are three lanes of traffic and the innermost lane, known as the hard shoulder, is one long layby parallel to the road on which vehicles can stop if they break down or have a flat tyre.
The Department for Transport has spent £1.5 billion digging up hundreds of miles of traditional motorway, burying sensors under the road and relaying them, removing the hard shoulder and replacing it with occasional laybys.
The idea is that if a car or a truck breaks down in a lane or there is an accident the overhead gantries will show a red X and motorists will know not to drive in that lane, thus avoiding a pile-up.
A coroner's decided a lack of a hard shoulder in a smart motorway on the M1 contributed to the deaths of two men including one from Mansfield. 22yo Alexandru Murgeanu was among two killed when a lorry hit their vehicles after they stopped after a minor collision #CapitalReports pic.twitter.com/oQ7WXkTUZz— Capital Midlands News (@CapitalMidsNews) January 18, 2021
In 2019 Edmund King, the president of the Royal Automobile Association (RAC) told Sputnik the design of smart motorways was inherently dangerous and said: "I don’t care what their stats show, I know that if I am broken down I want to get out of a live lane. You just have to hear the fear in the voice of the AA men who are dealing with these incidents, when you have the children crying in the background".
Mr Mercer's widow Claire is suing Highways England over smart motorways and is taking the case to the High Court.
Helen Smith, a lawyer representing Mrs Mercer said: "Claire has suffered a truly unspeakable loss…and is understandably determined to get answers regarding how Jason’s death could have happened".
She added: "The safety of smart motorways which operate without a hard shoulder has been called into question on a number of occasions in recent years and the number of fatalities on such routes both locally and nationwide is a cause for concern".
The Polish lorry driver whose truck killed Mr Mercer and Mr Murgeanu was jailed last year after admitting causing their deaths by careless driving.
Does anyone else see an irony in the hooha about Smart Motorways where inattentive drivers kill other drivers but no hooha about deaths of pedestrians and cyclists caused by inattentive drivers on other roads?— Active Travel Macclesfield (@RichardNewstead) January 18, 2021
At the inquest on Monday, 18 January, Mr Szuba said he admitted he had not been paying full attention on the night of the crash but he added: "If there had been a hard shoulder on this bit of motorway, the collision would have been avoidable. I would have driven past these two cars as it would be safer and they would have been able to come home safely and I would be able to come back home".
Highways England said many of the points raised by the coroner had been addressed "in the government's Smart Motorway Evidence Stocktake and Action Plan of March 2020" but added: "We will carefully consider any further comments raised by the coroner once we receive the report”.
But Naomi Watson, a teacher from London, told Sputnik: "I was driving home from work on the M25 last year. I was in the inside lane when a huge lorry which was overtaking me suddenly started to veer into my lane. I presume he didn’t see me but fortunately I could pull over onto the hard shoulder. It was terrifying. If there had not been a hard shoulder I could have been killed. Smart motorways just aren't safe."