01:16 GMT13 May 2021
Listen Live
    Get short URL

    German Chancellor Angela Merkel’s recent migration row with the country’s interior minister, Horst Seehofer has cast a shadow on the future of Germany’s coalition government. Sputnik has discussed it with Philip Anderson, a migration researcher and academic of the Regensburg University of Applied Sciences based in Bavaria.

    Sputnik: If this ultimatum is not fulfilled, what consequences will that have Angela Merkel and can you comment on her actual position right now in terms of government and support and what should she really do to preserve her position?

    Philip Anderson: As we all know, she is always a person who claims to negotiate or to maintain dialogue in any kind of situation. That's the attitude she's taking here: not being confrontational because she knows that, on the one hand, the CSU is under pressure, and the CSU, to some extent, is behaving irrationally. But she knows what the price could be if her coalition falls apart, that would be catastrophic for the German government; it would have repercussions, reverberations, across Europe. So she is prepared to compromise to some extent, some would say, facing a dictate on the part of the CSU politicians that she's got to get some kind of agreement from Europe.

    In the next two weeks, ideally, there should be some kind of de-escalation so that even if she doesn't manage to attain a radical change in policy, which is very unlikely, they'd be able to say, "Well, she's done her best, lets come to some kind of agreement on this."

    READ MORE: German Government in Jeopardy Amid CSU/CDU Row Over Tougher Refugee Policy

    What we can definitely say is that CSU behind the scenes must be under enormous pressure from all the CDU's sister parties and their associations in the other 15 German states. And there is one point of potential massive pressure, which the CDU can subject the party here in the south, too.

    If the CSU really went for the break, if they said "OK, we don't care, we're prepared to allow the coalition to go under," then what the CDU can say is "OK, in the case of the next election, we, as an independent party, will also stand for election and take some of your votes."

    That's the ultimate threat that was tried once 40-50 years ago when there was a huge conflict between the so-called "sister parties." And if they came to the crunch, that's what Angela Merkel's party could say this time, "OK, you insist on following your line, there's gonna be a breakup. Then, when you have your election in October, we should have an independent party as candidates from a conservative alternative. That would be really frightening for the CSU. So, I think, they would retreat from the brink, if it came to that sort of break.

    Sputnik: Do you perceive a threat that this coalition could actually fall apart right now?

    Philip Anderson: Yes, there is a threat. This is a real danger. Everything you read in the media, in the German media and the international media indicates that in a way — I don't want to be too polemical about this — the CSU are behaving like fire-raisers. They're standing in the lobby of the building, they've got torches in their hands and they're saying, "Shall we chant, shan't we?" Of course, that's extraordinarily dangerous. Things could get out of control.

    READ MORE: Berlin on Satirical Tweet on CDU/CSU Alliance Collapse: 'We Should Keep Calm'

    Sputnik: What would be the consequences if it did fall apart?

    Philip Anderson: To some extent, we'd have to say, incalculable. It would almost certainly lead to Angela Merkel having to resign and not being able to continue as chancellor. If that were the case, then there would be new elections, and the biggest danger of this is that it could lead to a kind of populist policy, which the CSU has been pushing, actually promotes the interest of the party to their right, Alternative for Germany. The main thing that Alternative for Germany has been pushing in terms of personnel policy-making has been saying, "Merkel must go."

    Now, I think, if there would be new elections, parties to the right, say, Alternative for Germany, would come about and say, "Give us your votes. We will push for an alternative."

    If that degree of destabilization took place within the German body politic, there would be an even stronger right-wing party within parliament — and no single figure in the CDU they could unite around. With an extremely divisive culture of bitterness between the main parties, the main conservative parties at least, then what would happen in terms of building a new coalition? And how would that affect Europe? The main stabilizing factor in many ways, in terms of rising populism, economic insecurity, people's fears, etc., has been Germany under Merkel. What would happen if that's suddenly gone and torpedoed by her own side? Psychologically, and in terms of voters' behavior, the consequences would be incalculable.

    The views and opinions expressed by Philip Anderson are those of the speaker and do not necessarily reflect the position of Sputnik.

    The views and opinions expressed in the article do not necessarily reflect those of Sputnik.


    Merkel's 'Destiny Day': German Chancellor Takes Her Refugee Headache to EU Level
    German Interior Minister to Deliver Ultimatum on Migration to Merkel - Reports
    Germans Rush to Twitter to Blame Merkel for World Cup's First Defeat From Mexico
    'I Can't Work With The Woman': Minister Slams Merkel Amid Refugee Row – Report
    de-escalation, consequences, ultimatum, CSU, CDU, Alternative for Germany (AfD), Angela Merkel, Germany
    Community standardsDiscussion