08:05 GMT +318 July 2019
Listen Live
    A boy sits on a swing near a building, which was damaged during fighting between Kiev and Donbass forces, as an armoured personnel carrier (APC) of the Ukrainian armed forces is seen nearby in Avdeyevka near Donetsk. June 7, 2015.

    Italian TV Relays Plight of Donbass From Standpoint of Residents

    © REUTERS / Gleb Garanich
    Opinion
    Get short URL
    4424

    A report broadcast by Italy's news program TG2 provides an account of the ill-fated moments that turned Donetsk, which proudly hosted the UEFA European soccer championship four short years ago, into a half-abandoned, war-wracked community on the precipice of invasion.

    (By Daniele Pozzati) — This is not your average western media coverage of the war in Donbass. Gone is the familiar narrative of "Russian aggression," and there are no unfounded allegations of Moscow's meddling. Donbass militia leaders and Ukrainians politicians are also absent.

    The plight of Donbass is instead seen through its inhabitants' eyes: the reportage mentions those who left, but focuses on those who have stayed, especially on those who are fighting — for survival, but also literally, in the local militias.

    "We defend our children, our elderly, our homes," says a young female soldier of the Novorossiya Armed Forces. "This is what patriotism means."

    Here, where people tried to follow in Crimea's footsteps, the former host city of the UEFA Euro 2012 championship is no longer. Kiev is not talked about with hate or resentment, but as the capital of a foreign country that insists on reclaiming newly-independent territories.

    "Threatened by Kiev's new pro-Western coup government, the largely Russian population of Donetsk and Lugansk held a referendum to secede from Ukraine," recalls the narrating voice. "The resulting autonomous republics were backed by Russia, but opposed by the EU and the US."

    "The EU and the US mobilized in favor of Kiev to reconquer the two rebel territories: it has been war, violent and cruelty, since May 2014," continues the narrating voice as the cameraman zooms on the ruins of Donetsk airport, "whose destruction isolates the two republics from the rest of the world."

    The documentary offers numbers seldom addressed in the Western press: 9,000 dead, 22,000 wounded, and one and a half million refugees. "Towards Russia," says the reporter, clarifying where the terrified former residents fled.

    Ukraine's Anti-Terrorist-Operation is exposed, before millions of Italian viewers, for what alternative media have long showed it to be: a massacre of ordinary people. Their representatives had never committed terrorist acts, but simply demanded that the UN-sanctioned right of self-determination be applied to their communities.

    The documentary proceeds to address another much-ignored aspect of this war: the many children among the casualties. We see a ceremony where friends, relatives and other attendees release 101 white balloons into the air, in memory of each child who "died under Ukrainian fire."

    Aerial views of the countryside show Nikishino, a utterly devastated village. "There are many villages like this between Donetsk and Lugansk," explains the reporter, "completely eviscerated by Ukrainian bombs."

    In the cities we see people who have adapted, for the past two years, to live in the atomic bunkers built during the Cold War which are now used to escape a hot one. A war, the reporter points out, "that has never really stopped."

    Kiev has indeed long resumed shelling these areas. Its daily violations of the Minsk II agreements, as documented by OCSE, have reached alarming levels. In the report we also learn that only last week, a Ukrainian Battalion had moved in near the airport, in an attempt to reconquer the long fought-over area.

    Maurizio Blondet, a senior Italian journalist for L’ Avvenire, a major Catholic daily, is puzzled by the documentary: "One swallow does not make a summer," he says, "I do not think that RAI has changed its editorial line regarding the Ukraine crisis."

    Coverage of the Ukraine crisis by the Italian mainstream media has indeed been in line with other Western countries, i.e. pro-Kiev, if somewhat less belligerent in tone.

    "This is a rare example of a documentary which was produced in the territory of the rebel provinces," confirms Fulvio Scaglione, another experience journalist, author and former editor of Famiglia Cristiana, Italy's Catholic weekly: "Such reports are usually produced in Ukraine. The resulting angle, always Ukrainian."

    Scaglione, who has written extensively about the Ukrainian and Middle Eastern crises, notices within the population at large a growing skepticism towards the mainstream account of major international crises: "It is too homogeneous and repetitive to be convincing, and the Ukraine crisis, just like Syria and, before it, Iraq, is no exception."

    "Everybody has understood that, within such crises, the rights and wrongs are never fully with either side. But this is exactly how the mainstream media keep portraying them."

    Related:

    Russian OSCE Envoy Warns Kiev Against Unilateral Policy on Donbass Status
    Poroshenko Signs Bill on Allocating Over $120 Mln for Donbass Restoration
    Moscow 'Making Obvious Efforts to Resolve Situation in Donbass'
    Ukrainian FM: Russian Participation in OSCEMission to Donbass 'Abstraction'
    Ukraine Security Service Against Data Leaks on Reporters Working in Donbass
    Tags:
    TV, TV channel, journalism, propaganda, Minsk protocol, Ukrainian crisis, Donbass, Italy, Ukraine
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik