07:26 GMT +327 February 2017
Live
    US President Barack Obama speaks to reporters following a National Security Council meeting

    Obama Suffers Major Setbacks on Key Foreign Policy Goals in 2016

    © AFP 2016/ JIM WATSON
    World
    Get short URL
    Year in Review: Highlights of 2016 (25)
    323151

    US foreign policy failures were not relegated to Syria in 2016, exemplified most notably by growing instability in Afghanistan, deteriorating relations with Turkey, and Washington’s support for a Saudi-led offensive in Yemen that has killed scores of civilians, among other challenges.

    Afghanistan

    The United States failed to make progress in 2016 on its goal of stabilizing Afghanistan evidenced by a resurgent Taliban and rising casualties among Afghan security forces. The year was also marked by the abject failure of several reconstruction projects plagued by corruption, fraud and incompetence along with controversies over possible US war crimes.

    Since 2002, US Congress has appropriated $113 billion into rebuilding Afghanistan, with sixty percent of funding dedicated to training and developing an indigenous security force — one that can hopefully withstand Taliban onslaughts in the wake of a US-NATO drawdown.

    "The Taliban now controls more territory than at any time since 2001," US Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR) chief John Sopko said in an audit report released on January 30, 2016. "Afghanistan proved even more dangerous than it was a year ago."

    After the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) wound up its large-scale mission in Afghanistan at the end of 2014, the United States and NATO launched Operation Resolute Support — a follow-on mission focused on advising and assisting local forces and counterterrorism operations.

    President Barack Obama intended to drawdown US forces to a residual presence in Afghanistan by 2017, but the resurgence of the Taliban and rise of Daesh forced him to reverse course.

    "I am announcing an additional adjustment to our posture. Instead of going down to 5,500 by the end of this year, the United States will maintain approximately 8,400 troops in Afghanistan into next year through the end of my administration," Obama announced in July.

    NATO Resolute Support Mission Commander Gen. John Nicholson said in a briefing in September he was worried by the rising casualty rate among Afghan security forces while human rights groups decried the spike in civilian deaths.

    The US military reported that 5,523 ANDSF service members were killed and an additional 9,665 wounded in the first eight months of 2016 for a total of 15,188, a casualty rate military officials have said is running 20 percent higher than 2015.

    The UN Assistance Mission in Afghanistan reported that the 1,601 civilians killed and 3,565 injured in the first six months of 2016, the highest recorded since 2009.

    Corruption and wasteful spending was another major problem that plagued US reconstruction efforts in 2016. SIGAR revealed that US taxpayer money has been wasted and all the blame cannot be placed on Afghan President Ashraf Ghani and CEO Abdullah Abdullah.

    "The United States contributed to the growth of corruption by injecting tens of billions of dollars into the Afghan economy, using flawed oversight and contracting practices, and partnering with malign powerbrokers," SIGAR said in a report published on September 14.

    The US military sparked controversy in April when the Pentagon announced the results of a probe into the 2015 US airstrike on a hospital in Kunduz that killed more than 40 staff and patients. The US military claimed the strike did not constitute a war crime because pilots did not "intentionally" target civilians.

    In November, in a similar vein, the United States refuted an International Criminal Court (ICC) probe that found US personnel may be guilty of war crimes for torturing prisoners.

    "We [the United States] do not believe that an ICC examination or investigation with respect to the actions of US personnel in relation to the situation in Afghanistan is warranted or appropriate," State Department spokesperson Elizabeth Trudeau told reporters November 15. "We believe that we have national systems of accountability that are more than sufficient."

    All signs indicate the war in Afghanistan is not likely to end anytime soon in light of nonexistent peace talks between the government and insurgents and the fact Pakistan continues to provide safe haven to the Haqqani network and other Taliban leaders, according to a Pentagon report released in December.

    Turkey

    US relations with NATO ally Turkey began deteriorating at the outset of 2016 primarily due to Washington’s support for Syrian Kurdish Democratic Union Party (PYD) forces and its refusal to hand over Muslim cleric Fethullah Gulen, who Ankara has accused of playing a key role in the July coup attempt.

    The US military has provided support to PYD fighters to counter Daesh in Syria despite the fact Ankara considers the PYD to be an affiliate of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK), a designated terrorist outfit which has been fighting for independence from Turkey since 1984.

    On February 10, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan delivered an ultimatum to Washington during an address in Ankara, asking the US government to choose between Turkey or the PYD. Later in the year, Turkish officials claimed that half of the US arms shipped to Kurdish fighters end up in the hands of Daesh.

    After the July 15 military coup attempt in Turkey, which was suppressed the following day after 240 people were killed and some 2,000 wounded, Ankara demanded that the United States hand over Gulen who was living in the US state of Pennsylvania since 1999.

    In October, Erdogan warned Washington that Turkey could "resort to very serious steps" if the United States continued to delay Gulen’s extradition.

    The State Department, for its part, said the Justice Department must review the evidence provided by Turkey to validate a crime was committed and get a court order authorizing the extradition.

    Erdogan, two months later, said he was "disillusioned" with Obama for not handing over Gulen in an expeditious manner as Turkey would have done upon Washington’s request.

    "I served both as a prime minister and president in this country [Turkey], and whenever the United States requested extradition of those kinds of terrorists, I handed them over," Erdogan told CBS News. "Obama also should have done it and handed that man to us."

    Washington’s repeated criticism of alleged human rights abuses in Turkey, ranging from the detention of thousands of opposition figures, journalists, academics and other regime critics and violence against Kurdish citizens, have also rankled Turkish officials.

    Yemen

    The United States has garnered international opprobrium for supporting and providing weaponry to Saudi Arabia which is leading a Sunni State coalition in conducting airstrikes on positions in Yemen that have killed scores of civilians, including strikes on hospitals, weddings, funerals and markets.

    The UN estimates that more than 10,000 civilians have been killed or wounded during the campaign since the campaign was launched in March, 2015.

    The Saudi-led coalition at the request of the government headed by Abd Rabbuh Mansur Hadi, has been targeting Shiite Houthi rebels supported by army units loyal to former Yemeni President Ali Abdullah Saleh.

    In March, the International Campaign to Ban Landmines-Cluster Munition Coalition reported that most of the cluster munitions used by the Saudi-led coalition had been produced in the United States. As a result, several human rights groups have called on Washington to ban weapons sales to Saudi Arabia.

    In August, a group of 60 US lawmakers called on Obama to postpone the sale of $1.15 billion worth of arms and ammunition to Saudi Arabia because of the impact Riyadh’s military campaign has had on civilians in Yemen.

    Congressman Ted Lieu in a letter to Secretary of State John Kerry expressed concerns that the United States might be liable for war crimes in Yemen.

    "Immediately stopping the aiding and abetting of the Saudi military coalition would not only help reduce the legal risk to US officials, it would send a strong message to the world that the US respects the Law of War and basic human rights," Lieu said on October 13.

    Kerry, meanwhile, has failed in his efforts to support a durable UN-brokered ceasefire between the warring parties in Yemen.

    Other Challenges

    The United States and its allies failed to reverse declining security conditions in civil war-torn Libya, which descended into chaos after the US-backed military intervention in 2011 that overthrew longstanding leader Muammar Gaddafi, allowing Daesh to gain a foothold in the country.

    In September, the UN Human Rights Council reported that terrorist groups, most notably Daesh, have been increasing activities in Libya. Meanwhile, 400,000 people have been internally displaced, with many living in dire conditions, while the UN-backed "unity" government in Tripoli has so far failed to meet its entire raison d’etre — that being, uniting the country.

    Relations with China took a turn for the worse in 2016 after the United States sent a warship through the South China Sea, the center of controversy in the region due to conflicting claims over territory between Beijing and several other countries.

    The Obama administration suffered a significant setback with the failure to pass the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) agreement, which the White House had touted as a landmark trade deal.

    US support of Ukraine showed little results as Kiev failed to abide the Minsk accords and continues to be plagued by corruption and debt.

    The US-led coalition has made mild gains in 2016 in the fight against Daesh in Iraq, however, some operations have led to blowback in Syria, such as the offensive to retake Mosul.

    "The process of squeezing of large groups out of Iraq for various reasons is evident, which allows them to form large terrorist groups on the Syrian territory and launch offensive actions," Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov told reporters on December 12.

    The United States saw mixed results in its relations with Tehran as well – such as taking steps to implement the nuclear agreement while clashing on the high seas. In January, Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) seized a US navy ship that had inadvertently entered Iranian waters due to a mechanical malfunction.

    The United States took positive steps towards normalizing relations with Cuba, however, Obama failed to close the detention center in Guantanamo Bay – a promise he made upon entering office in 2009.

    Obama failed to salvage his foreign policy legacy in 2016 and will leave countries like Afghanistan, Yemen, Libya and Syria, among others, more unstable than when he took office eight years ago. Moreover, there is a high probability Obama’s few foreign policy achievements — such as the historic breakthrough in US-Cuban relations — might be reversed by the incoming administration of President-elect Donald Trump.

    Topic:
    Year in Review: Highlights of 2016 (25)

    Related:

    The US Wars No One is Talking About and Obama's Foreign Policy Legacy
    'Failed Foreign Policy Leader': Moscow Helps Obama Save Face, Again
    Obama's Flawed Foreign Policy Brings Russian Jets to Iranian Airbase - Senator
    Obama Defends Violent Foreign Policy That Bred Terror, Made World Less Safe
    Tags:
    Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), Daesh, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Fethullah Gulen, Barack Obama, Mosul, Libya, Iraq, Syria, Ukraine, Yemen, Afghanistan, United States
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik
    • Сomment

    All comments

    • avatar
      jas
      This is an outstanding article, Sputnik. Thank you. I am not anti-Obama for personal reasons. He isn't a good POTUS, one failure after another. He doesn't even like the US. He keeps saying how he thinks the US is a bad place.

      It will be beneficial to Cuba to stay away from the US because US business would demand the "right" to loot the country an steal land. Although I think it is a mistake for Trump to start confronting anyone, it will at least show the US as nothing more than a bully forcing its will on smaller countries. That's better than Cuba surrendering to a beast.

      Although Obama pretends to make peace with Iran or Cuba, I think the real plan is to loot and pillage. That seems to be the current western economic model.
    • avatar
      vigilante
      Obama has been naive by favoring political Islam in the Middle East as a way to move toward democracy. He was advised by the US allies, Israel, Saudi Arabia and Qatar that a 'moderate' Sunni Islam will bring peace to the region.
      What he missed is that Islam itself is in the middle of a crisis and could not become the backbone of the regions where there many brands of Islam. By pushing one brand over the other, Obama has inflamed the region. He will be remembered as the most naive president about the role of religion in the middle east.
      Trump is exactly the opposite. He is well aware that Islam is far from been united and the centuries old internal struggles within Islam can only bring violence, in the middle and in the west, including the USA. Therefore he prefers to avoid Islam altogether and let the Islam protagonists fight against each other in their own countries. This explain his strong rejection of emigrants from Moslem countries as he suspects they will bring their divisions on the US ground, similarly to the Sicilian mafias and that they will resort to uncontrolled violence.
      Trump is realistic: The middle east is going through a war of religions, and the USA has no role to play except preventing it to spill on the USA by all means except intervening on the ground.
      He trusts that he could benefit from Russia in preventing that as Russia has ambitions in the region and is ready to intervene, while the USA is not.
      Trump is ready to decrease the US influence in the region if this will protect the USA and allow countries in the region to find a modus vivendi on their own.
      Obama on his last days has realized that and has withdrawn from the Aleppo situation and has allowed Russia to take the lead.
      It is expected that Trump will expand on that by totally stopping the arming of rebels and sanctioning any country that support them, even if these countries are important commercial partners to the USA ( Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and Qatar)
      A new and promising approach.
    Show new comments (0)