00:19 GMT07 May 2021
Listen Live
    Get short URL

    The Republican tax plan that passed the US House of Representatives Tuesday afternoon appears to have violated procedural rules that must be followed for the Senate to vote on the bill, according to the ranking members of the Senate Finance and Senate Budget committees.

    "In the mad dash to provide tax breaks for their billionaire campaign contributors, our Republican colleagues forgot to comply with the rules of the Senate," Sens. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and Ron Wyden (D-OR) said in a Tuesday statement.

    "We applaud the [Senate] parliamentarian for determining that three provisions in this disastrous bill are in violation of the Byrd rule," the senators said, noting that they intend to "raise a point of order to remove these provisions from the conference report and require the House to vote on this bill again."

    "While Republicans met in SECRET for weeks, they thought the American people weren't paying attention — but we've been watching the ENTIRE TIME," Wyden posted on Twitter.

    The Byrd rule places limits on what can be passed through Congress under budget reconciliation procedures and stipulates that budget reconciliation legislation cannot contain "extraneous" provisions that don't have to do with finance and spending.

    In a notice to House legislators, the second highest ranking official in the House, Majority Leader Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-CA), advised members of the chamber "that an additional procedural vote on the Motion to Concur is expected tomorrow morning, which will clear the bill for President Trump's signature."

    ​According to the Senate parliamentarian, the bill was found in violation of the Byrd rule "for allowing the use of 529 savings accounts for home-schooling expenses, the short title: ‘The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act,' and part of the criteria used to determine whether the endowments of private universities are subject to the legislation's new excise tax."

    "These provisions may be struck from the conference report absent 60 votes," the parliamentarian said, noting that the violations were "impermissible."

    "I wouldn't read too much into this. Somebody screwed up… It's not the end of Western civilization. We had the votes, we'll have the votes tomorrow," Senator John Kennedy (R-LA) told Meet the Press.

    Skeptics of the bill have charged that the tax bill already violated the Byrd rule in a separate sense from the points mentioned by the parliamentarian, namely the part of the rule stating that bills cannot add more than $1.5 trillion to the national debt without requiring 60 votes to pass the senate.

    ​The Wharton School of Business at the University of Pennsylvania estimated Monday that the tax bill "increases debt by between $1.9 trillion and $2.2 trillion over the next decade." Incidentally, US President Donald Trump graduated from Wharton in 1968.

    ​The tax bill "clearly violated the Byrd rule, most significantly by adding to the deficit beyond the budget window," the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, a non-partisan Washington-based think tank, reported November 7.


    US House Republicans Push Through Major Tax Reform Bill
    President Trump Expects Tax Reform to Produce 4-6-Percent GDP Growth
    Indian Tax Authorities Probe 500K Bitcoin Traders for Alleged Tax Evasion
    Brussels' Tax Haven Blacklist Should Include Four EU Members – Oxfam Tax Expert
    'Biggest Dodge?' How George Soros Can Hide $18 Billion From US Tax Authorities
    national debt, tax, University of Pennsylvania, Ron Wyden, Bernie Sanders, US
    Community standardsDiscussion