19:27 GMT +308 December 2019
Listen Live
    FILE - In this Nov. 5, 2014 file photo, Sgt. Chris Wicklund of the Burnsville, Minn., Police Department wears a body camera beneath his microphone

    New Mexico Police Accused of Deleting, Editing Cop Shooting Footage

    © AP Photo / Jim Mone
    US
    Get short URL
    156
    Subscribe

    A former records supervisor for the Albuquerque Police Department has alleged in a sworn affidavit that officials altered or deleted body-camera video showing police shootings in at least two cases.

    Reynaldo Chavez alleged in his affidavit that SD memory cards from the cameras were easy to lose, and that he specifically witnessed assistant police chief Robert Huntsman say “we can make this disappear,” while discussing an officer’s body camera, New Mexico’s In Depth reports.

    Chavez claimed that, in the case of the 2014 fatal police shooting of suspected car thief Mary Hawkes, body camera footage of three officers present during the incident was altered or partially deleted.

    “Then-officer Dear fatally shot Mary Hawkes in April 2014 after a foot chase. She was suspected of stealing a truck. Controversy has surrounded the case from the beginning. Dear says Hawkes turned to face him, then pointed a gun at him. But a forensics analysis conducted by the Hawkes family’s expert shows that she was turning away from him and falling to the ground when he shot her in the back of the head,” In Depth detailed.

    The officer was wearing a functioning body camera during the shooting, but, according to the APD, it did not record. Other officers on the scene had portions of their video footage deleted, or “altered by changing the gradient of the resolution on the video.”

    A website called Evidence.com allows for the editing or deletion of body camera video, and Chavez claims that, by using their tools, the department was able to modify footage.

    “I was one of a handful of City of Albuquerque administrators instructed on how to edit in Evidence.com. I was able to see, via the Evidence.com audit trail, that people had in fact deleted and/or altered lapel camera video. Videos, other than Taser videos, could be uploaded to Evidence.com. We were able to build cases on Evidence.com. We were able to alter videos by inserting or blurring images on the videos or by removing images from the video,” the affidavit states.

    The affidavit also alleges that surveillance footage in the 2014 shooting of police informant Jeremy Robertson was deleted. Chavez said that the video has “the tell-tale signs that it has been altered and images that had been captured are now deleted. One of the deleted images captured the officers shooting Jeremy Robertson.”

    The nine-page affidavit explains that officers in multiple divisions of the APD were instructed not to write reports until after they reviewed their video footage.

    “If the videos had no images considered harmful to the department, the officers were permitted to write in their reports that ‘they had recorded a given incident,’” In Depth explains. “But if images deemed ‘problematic’ for the department were found, officers were instructed not to mention a recording in the report or to write ‘the recording equipment had malfunctioned’ or the officer had failed to turn it on.”

    If an officer wrote a report, but the recording was deemed damaging to the department, Chavez alleges that “the video would be altered or corrupted.”

    The affidavit is part of a civil-rights lawsuit filed by the family of Hawke against Jeremy Dear, the officer who shot her, as well as the department, and the city. The family hopes that Chavez’s affidavit will compel the city to release audit logs that will show who altered or deleted video evidence. The city has fought the release of the logs.

    Chavez was fired from the department in August 2015, and filed a whistleblower lawsuit in January arguing that his termination occurred because he raised concerns after the department ordered him to deny public-records requests in high-profile cases, a practice that is against the law. Representatives for city deny that this was the reason why his employment was terminated.

    The allegations made by Chavez have led to renewed questions in the case of the police shooting of James Boyd, a homeless camper. Two APD officers were charged with murder in the case, but a mistrial was declared last month.

    One of the officers claimed that he had turned on his body camera, but no video was recorded. In the Boyd case, Chavez alleges that he was told to “deny, withhold, obstruct, conceal, or even destroy records.”

    “These are extremely concerning allegations,” District Attorney Kari Brandenburg has stated. “This throws everything into question. As prosecutors, we have to rely on what we get and the integrity of everyone in the process. These kinds of allegations raise so many questions.”

    Related:

    Potential Active Shooter at Albuquerque City Hall, Reports
    Prosecutors: Albuquerque Cops Unlawfully Opened Fire, Killing Homeless Man
    Prom-munism: Albuquerque High School Students to Hold Communist Themed Prom
    Albuquerque Parents Shot by Toddler Son to Face Charges
    Two Albuquerque Officers Charged with Murder of Homeless Camper (VIDEO)
    Tags:
    Police Shooting, Police Misconduct, Albuquerque Police, Jeremy Robertson, Mary Hawkes, Reynaldo Chavez, New Mexico, Albuquerque
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik