17:58 GMT +326 March 2017
    Official start of sales of iPhone 5s and iPhone 5c in Moscow

    Is Apple Being Forced to Hack Not One But a Dozen iPhones?

    © Sputnik/ Konstantin Rodikov
    Get short URL

    The unlocking of the San Bernardino iPhone may be the "tip of the iceberg." According to the Wall Street Journal, the US Justice Department is currently trying to force Apple to hack into "about a dozen" iPhones around the US.

    Sources have told the Journal that prosecutors in about a dozen other cases have all attempted to use the 1789 All Writs Act to make the tech giant bypass the phone's passcode to access data. The Journal claims the cases "don't involve terrorism charges".

    So the FBIs claim that the San Bernardino iPhone case is unique and "tailored for and limited to this particular phone" may not be true.

    The San Bernardino iPhone remains at the center of the debate between personal privacy and government access to encrypted data. As part of their counterterror investigation into the fatal shooting of 14 people in California, the FBI want tech giant Apple to unlock the phone belonging to Syed Rizwan Farook who carried out the mass shooting with his wife.

    This undated photo provided by the California Department of Motor Vehicles shows Syed Rizwan Farook who has been named as the suspect in the San Bernardino, Calif., shootings.
    © AP Photo/ California DMV
    This undated photo provided by the California Department of Motor Vehicles shows Syed Rizwan Farook who has been named as the suspect in the San Bernardino, Calif., shootings.

    The couple were killed in a police shootout and US President Barack Obama defined the incident as an act of terrorism. 

    The cell phone that belonged to Farook ran the newer iOS9 operating system, which was built without a "backdoor" to its encrypted data, so there is no set of instructions, or a backdoor key that Apple can give to the FBI to unlock the phone — the technique doesn't exist.

    Apple has already assisted the FBI by handing over access to Farook's iCloud backups for his phone — but is resisting the order to develop a technique to hack into Farook's phone.

    Prosecutors claim that the hacking order only relates to Farook and is "tailored for and limited to this particular phone."

    "And the order will facilitate only the FBI's efforts to search this phone… Nor is compliance with the order a threat to other users of Apple products," the prosecutors said.

    But Tim Cook refutes the claim, suggesting that "once created, the technique could be used over and over again, on any number of devices… The [US] government is asking Apple to hack our own users and undermine decades of security advancements."

    In an essay written by Dr Eerke Boiten, computer and cyber security expert at the University of Kent, Dr Boiten links the strong stand Tim Cook has taken against hacking into Farook's phone and the evidence Apple submitted for the UK's draft Investigatory Powers Bill — dubbed the Snoopers' Charter.

    Apple said it would strongly resist being asked by the British government to bulk collect swathes of communications data from individual users and the "removal of electronic protection" which would give UK intelligence authorities and other government agencies to make similar requests like the FBI.

    Boiten suggests Apple's CEO Tim Cook is not just about putting his customers first — but "really Cook chose to make a stand against governments."

    "Companies cannot meaningfully offer security and privacy measures to their customers if they are simultaneously forced to subvert them for governments, with all the risks involved," Dr Boiten writes.


    EU Data Chief Against iPhone Backdoor Access Demanded by FBI
    FBI's San Bernardino iPhone Hack Attempt Is Stab at Wider Legal Precedent
    US Seeks Court to Force Apple to Unlock iPhone of San Bernardino Shooter
    Tech Giants Close Ranks Against FBI's Encryption Weakening Demands
    backdoor encryption access, encryption, iPhone, San Bernardino shooting, Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), Wall Street Journal, US Justice Department, Apple, Tim Cook, United States
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik
    • Сomment

    All comments

    • avatar
      And Americans think they have human rights or constitutional rights. 350 million people and no one files a suite against their criminal government. Americans either lack knowledge or are frightened of their government.
      You have no rights if you don't fight for them. Rights are not hap hazard, some don't get them and others do. Rights are rights are rights are rights. Never to be abridged or denied.
    • avatar
      Oh come on, the Federal Government, has long had the information it needs to do anything it wants to any phone in the world, Apple phones included and especially. Apple didn't get to be one of if not the biggest (gangland) corporation in the world by refusing the Federal Government, in bed with Israel, anything it asks. Like the Boozer's during prohibition, only certain of them had a path cleared for them, all the way to the Bank, so it is with Apple and just about every other major corporation in the world today, all Rothschild controlled, all in with the Federal Government (the paid off Politicians), all of them feeding off the people who are nothing to them except a few dollars more. It is a guise this seemingly difficulty between the Federal Government and Apple, meant to make people think they can do anything they want with their Apple, but no other phone of course, and the Government can't do anything about it. Go ahead Apple user, try it out, you'll find out, Apple, Smapple, it don't matter, all of them are in the pocket of the Rothschild Jewish Mafia and that means all of them are wide open to disclosure whenever Rothschild wants them to be. Closed, when in the case of Rothschild's criminal gang, Rothschild, wants them closed. What an absurdity this game is, as if we never learn and some don't. This crap, is just to another BS game, intending to increase sales to the Jews, Apple, outfit.
    Show new comments (0)