Jorge I. Melendez was arrested in May 2012 after federal agents discovered he was growing more than 1,000 marijuana plants in a warehouse he owned on South Park Avenue. The four annual harvests helped Melendez gain more than $40,000 a year.
Melendez’s back pay covers the 26 months in which his case was pending before he pleaded guilty in U.S. District Court last August. Under contractual obligations, that’s when he should have been fired.
Departmental charges are always put on hold until the case against an officer is resolved due to issues involving the Fifth Amendment and self-incrimination, according to police officials.
The PBA says the police department could have avoided the issue of back pay had it fired Melendez through an expedited arbitration process while keeping him on the payroll for a brief period until due process could play out.
Nonetheless, police sources argue that Melendez would still have collected about $200,000 had he been suspended with pay under the union contract.
In his ruling, arbitrator Jeffrey M. Selchick said Derenda’s decision was understandable but it still violated the contract.
“While the commissioner’s perception of the grievant’s wrongdoing was reasonable and well founded, the procedures which the parties agreed they would follow did not permit the commissioner, as he did, to summarily discharge the grievant,” said Selchick.
The city which argued that Melendez was “the epitome of a faithless servant” and not “entitled to recover compensation,” plans to appeal the arbitrator’s ruling.
Melendez is currently serving a five-year sentence at McKean Federal Correctional Institution in Lewis Run, Pennsylvania..
He is expected to be released on June 22, 2018.