A 'Helping Hand': Newly-Crowned Soft Power Champ France Faces Stiff Competition

© AFP 2023 / LUDOVIC MARINA worker arranges European flags alongside French national flags on the railings outside the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Paris (File)
A worker arranges European flags alongside French national flags on the railings outside the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Paris (File) - Sputnik International
Subscribe
France's leading position in a recent list of "soft power" exponents is being celebrated in France but makes little positive difference to the lives of French people, Paris-based analyst Christian Harbulot told Sputnik France.

French President Emmanuel Macron reacts after a meeting with the International Olympic Committee (IOC) Evaluation Commission at the Elysee Place in Paris, France May 16, 2017. - Sputnik International
Macron's Election Helped France to Become World Leader in Soft Power - Survey
France has become the world's most influential country when it comes to "soft power," according to the recently-published 2017 Soft Power 30 Index, a ranking compiled by the University of Southern California's Center of Public Diplomacy (CPD).

France clinched the top spot ahead of the UK, which was awarded second place for the second year running. Last year's leader, the US, slipped to third place in this year's ranking because of "a combination of strong objective soft power metrics and unfavorable polling results," the CPD said.

The concept of "soft power" was coined by Harvard University political scientist Joseph Nye in the late 1980s, to describe a state's ability to enforce its own foreign policy interests by appealing to other states in an effort to shape their long-term attitudes.

Christian Harbulot, director of the Paris-based "l'Ecole de Guerre Economique," (Economic Warfare School), told Sputnik France that the "soft power" battle is just as ruthless as that of "hard power," despite the name.

"In my opinion, this is an inaccurate expression. The concept of soft power is an extremely sugarcoated way of viewing this subject. In the 1990s, prior to the popularization of this concept …, so-called social learning was considered, based on a number of humanistic or humanitarian principles of particular countries or economies. They developed a strategy of conquering the market which was, of course, not made public."

Harbulot said that the kind of force used by France and other countries to conquer markets around the world "is certainly not a 'soft force,' because when you interpret it in terms of the forces which are used, it is clear that it isn't true."

"There is a winner and a loser. The winner is the one who controls the situation, extends a helping hand, promotes the implementation of certain principles and, in the final analysis, is not seen as a strategist but rather as someone who is making an effort to achieve a specific goal."

A flag from the 1956 Hungarian Revolution on the memorial to the victims located outside the Hungarian Parliament Building - Sputnik International
'Step Away' From EU Values: US Warns Hungary Against Adopting NGO Law
The high rating for France's soft power might delight politicians, but ordinary French people have little to gain from it, Harbulot continued.

"In France today they are congratulating themselves, they are all pleased that France is at the top of the soft power list. It creates an appearance but it doesn't make French people richer, makes very little difference to employment, it doesn't strengthen our industry. It doesn't orient us toward new goals, particularly in the digital economy. I would say we are in a miserable position."

When he used the term, Joseph Nye contrasted it with the hard or command power of ordering others to do what you want. Harbulot told Sputnik that non-governmental organizations (NGOs) represent another powerful force used to influence the development of countries.

"Today, there is a new form of power which is neither military presence, nor diplomacy, but is based on the art of war, to some extent. You have to pretend to be a person who wants to do good, to extend a helping hand. The best way to disguise this kind of influence, which is based on 'social learning,' is to create an NGO or foundation. This is a forceful player in civil society which strives to draw as little attention as possible," the analyst said.

Newsfeed
0
To participate in the discussion
log in or register
loader
Chats
Заголовок открываемого материала