07:21 GMT +319 October 2019
Listen Live
    Egyptian President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi (C) meets with Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov (4th L), Russian Defence Minister Sergei Shoigu (5th L) and other delegates from Egypt and Russia at the Ittihadiya presidential palace in Cairo, Egypt May 29, 2017 in this handout picture courtesy of the Egyptian Presidency

    Could Egypt Become Russia's Springboard to the Middle East?

    © REUTERS / The Egyptian Presidency
    Politics
    Get short URL
    5315
    Subscribe

    On Monday, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov and Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu held a "2+2" format meeting with their Egyptian counterparts in Cairo to discuss the crises in Syria, Libya, and bilateral military-technical cooperation. Political scientist Gevorg Mirzayan commented on the development of the mutual relations.

    Before meeting with Egypt's Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukry and Defense Minister Sedki Sobhy, Sergei Lavrov and Sergei Shoigu were welcomed by Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi.

    Political scientist Gevorg Mirzayan, Associate Professor at the Department of Political Sciences of Finance University under the Government of the Russian Federation, commented on the visit and reviewed what thorny issues are still left in the relationship between the two countries.

    Why the tables have turned

    "Such a warm welcome can be explained very simply: over the last years, Russian-Egyptian relations have been experiencing a renaissance as Cairo, which left Moscow for Washington in the 1970s, is now returning to its "home harbor," Mirzayan ironically writes in his article for Sputnik.

    "Egypt has become very disappointed with its new wife – she is very beautiful and rich, however she’s turned out to be very capricious," Mirzayan describes Cairo's relations with Washington.

    He further elaborated that Egypt won't forget how the Americans threatened to freeze all arms shipments to the Egyptians if they didn’t return the ousted Islamist President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi to power. Mirzayan continued by saying that Trump looks far more competent than Obama and won't be distracted by such trifles as human rights, the inhumane attitude towards Islamists and the clamp-down on NGOs (on Monday, el-Sisi signed into law a bill which restricts NGO activity to developmental and social work and introduces jail terms for non-compliance).

    However the US Congress will object to this. And until Trump does not tame the Capitol, it is dangerous for Egypt to rely in full on Washington, the political analyst says.

    "This is exactly why Egypt started looking for a new partner, predictable, pragmatic and reliable, and found it in Russia. This partially explains why the agenda of the talks was so broad. Apart from bilateral cooperation, it touched upon nearly all Middle Eastern issues. According to the Russian Foreign Ministry, it included the joint fight against terrorism, the settlement of the Syrian crisis, the Arab-Israeli settlement, the situation in Libya, Yemen, Iraq and the prospect of creating a zone in the Middle East free from weapons of mass destruction," Mirzayan says.

    However it does not mean that the sides readily found a common language: the two countries are too different, as are their interests and the understanding of sovereignty. Hence, the political analyst says, there were problems with the three issues on the agenda, namely the overall fight against terrorism, the fight against terrorism in Libya and the fight over Russian tourists.

    Fight against terrorism: Pick your sides

    With regards to the first issue, Mirzayan explained that el-Sisi has declared war on terrorism. However he further doubted that the Egyptians are really ready to follow through with their words.

    "They are greatly dependent on the major sponsor of terrorism, Saudi Arabia. Riyadh and its Gulf allies are major investors into, and creditors of, the Egyptian economy. Egypt is re-arming its army using Saudi money, including Russian arms purchases," he explained.

    This is why Egypt, according to some former high officials, does not want conflict with the Saudis. Cairo has a certain carte blanche to fight against terrorism on the Sinai peninsula and a certain room to maneuver, for example, not to send its army to fight for the Saudi interests in Yemen. However Cairo won't risk fighting against Saudi-backed groups in Syria. That is why Russia should not count on its support, the political analyst explained.

    Don't bomb there, bomb here

    However the Egyptians are ready to cooperate with Moscow in the fight against terrorism, Mirzayan says. Not in Syria, but in another country, "permitted" by Riyadh. Egypt wants to pull Russia into the operations in Libya.

    It still remains a question whether Moscow wants to be pulled in, he further explains. On the one hand, it is a very attractive offer which can bring not only direct economic benefits (the Kremlin will most probably reserve certain contracts on the restoration of the country as a payment for its disturbance). It is also politically attractive: Moscow will become a major stabilizer of the Islamic world, key fighter against terrorism and will get precious experience of field cooperation with the west in the elimination of the major threat to modern civilization.

    This cooperation could then boost a rapprochement between Russia and Europe.

    Are these potential benefits worth the risks which Russia will be forced to undertake, the political analyst further wonders. Libya is a tribal country and any attempt to find peace there through a political compromise is doomed to fail.

    The only chance is to act as Gaddafi, he suggests, eliminating and threatening whomever you can, and buying and then threatening the rest.

    Besides, Moscow has been actively participating in the Syrian operation and has been spending its resources on stabilizing the situation in Ukraine.

    Hence if Egypt and its western backers do not offer a fair price, the Kremlin will refuse to get involved in the Libyan campaign, Mirzayan says.

    Between money and pride

    With regards to the third issue on the agenda, and that is the fight for the Russian tourists, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov made it clear that the resumption of direct flights between Russia and Egypt would be possible only when Cairo fully implements security agreements reached after the 2015 tragedy involving a Russian passenger plane over the Sinai peninsula.

    "In this context, it is of fundamental importance to complete the investigation, as well as to implement the practical steps that have been agreed upon between our parties, and the full implementation of which will allow us to proceed with the practical resumption of flights," Lavrov said on Monday.

    The minister stressed that "the Russian side does not put forward any new conditions."

    Mirzayan added that Moscow's key demand is that Russian security experts should be present in Egyptian airports. Cairo however regards this as a breach of its sovereignty.

    "Egypt can be understood clearly, the country is trying to regains the role of a leader in the Arab world and can't afford such a demonstrative humiliation and distrust in its ability to control security in its airports," the political scientist says.

    However Moscow’s views are also clear, it can't afford another terrorist attack against its citizens in the Middle East. The Kremlin is not ready to sacrifice Russian interests for the sake of Egypt's loyalty, he concluded.

    Tags:
    fight against terrorism, negotiations, Syrian conflict, bilateral relations, tourism, talks, cooperation, Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, Sameh Shoukry, Gevorg Mirzayan, Sedki Sobhy, Sergei Lavrov, Sergei Shoigu, Syria, Russia, Middle East, Egypt, Libya
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik