08:48 GMT +315 December 2019
Listen Live
    (L-R) German Chancellor Angela Merkel, French President Francois Hollande and Italy's Prime Minister Matteo Renzi arrive for a press conference ahead of talks following the Brexit referendum at the chancellery in Berlin, on June 27, 2016.

    What's Behind EU States' Failure to Reach Consensus on New Anti-Russia Sanctions

    © AFP 2019 / John Macdougall
    Get short URL

    The European Union decided not to impose a new package of sanctions against Russia over the situation in Syria. However, the summit surprisingly showed that Europe is changing its stance towards Russia.

    Before the EU leaders’ summit in Brussels, the bloc threatened to introduce new sanctions against Moscow. Instead, the decision was made to keep the existing sanctions in place, without imposing new restrictions.

    Brussels wanted new sanctions over the Russian military campaign in Syria. Despite the fact that previously Moscow’s actions in Syria were not a big concern for Europe, recently Berlin and Paris blamed Russia for the deterioration of the humanitarian situation in the besieged Syrian city of Aleppo.

    France has taken a hardline stance on the issue. Initially, French leader Francois Hollande said that talks with Russia President Vladimir Putin on Aleppo did not make sense. However, in mid-October, Hollande confirmed readiness to continue talks with Moscow. During the summit in Brussels, Hollande said that it was crucial to start talks to end the crisis in Syria. Germany has also called for a firm stance toward Russia.

    Nevertheless, the Brussels summit showed the lack of unanimity between EU states over a hardline policy towards Moscow.

    There has long been a rift within the bloc over anti-Russian sanctions, said Vladimir Bruter, an expert at the International Institute for Humanitarian and Political Studies.

    As for the current situation, it is absurd because the "situation in Syria has nothing to do with Russia-EU relations" and many European politicians are frustrated with the situation, he told Gazeta.ru.

    Austria, Spain, Italy and Greece voiced against new sanctions at the summit, with Italian Prime Minister Matteo Renzi leading the pushback. Renzi is known for having good relations with both Putin and United States leader Barack Obama. He could persuade his colleagues that new sanctions against Moscow would make no sense.

    "We should do everything we can to come to a peaceful resolution of the Syrian crisis. But it’s hard to imagine that this could be related to anti-Russian sanctions," he told journalists after the summit.

    "Renzi came as the leader of those opposing sanctions against Russia. As a result, the Berlin-Paris axis gave up," an article in the Italian newspaper Il Foglio read.

    By doing this, Renzi restored the independency of Italy’s foreign policy, it read. This was also a signal to certain sectors of the Italian economy damaged by anti-Russian sanctions.

    "However, this surprising move is unlikely to isolate Italy because in this situation Renzi can rely on other European partner," according to the article.

    "I think this was a very positive moment because Renzi knows that the majority of Italians are against sanctions. This is why the Italian government has called for dialogue, not sanctions to settle the conflict," Tatyana Zonova from the Moscow State Institute of International Relations told RIA Novosti.

    EU leaders tried to persuade Serbia to join anti-Russian sanctions. Serbia is now in accession talks with Brussels. However, the Serbian Foreign Ministry responded that the country will not make decisions that contradict with its national interests.

    "From the beginning it was clear that the EU was not ready to mount pressure on Russia. Currently, the EU is incapable of conducting a coordinated foreign policy," said Sergei Utkin, a senior analyst at the Institute of Global Economics and International Relations.

    He noted that in the near future positive shifts are unlikely between Russia and the EU because the key troublemaking issues, Syria and Ukraine, "cannot be resolved at an EU summit."

    Washington has repeatedly asked Brussels to prolong sanctions. However, the presidential election is nearing in the US, so it will be the next US president who will form the strategy on the issue.

    The real revision of the EU sanctions policy against Russia is unlikely before next year. France and Germany will hold elections in 2017. The new leaders are expected to launch dialogue with Moscow.


    Sanctions on Russia: An Increasingly Hard Sell
    EU May Start Phasing Out Anti-Russian Sanctions in Spring – Senator
    Imposing New Sanctions Will Damage Russia's Ties With EU - Kremlin
    Renzi Takes Lead in Group of EU Leaders' Push Against New Sanctions on Russia
    anti-Russian sanctions, European Union, Angela Merkel, Francois Hollande, Syria, Russia, Europe
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik