11:02 GMT +316 December 2019
Listen Live
    A US soldier takes part in an exercise called Saber Junction at the military area in Hohenfels near Regensburg, southern Germany, Monday, Sept. 8, 2014

    Ghosts of Vietnam: US Military Solution in Syria 'Not the Way Forward'

    © AP Photo / Matthias Schrader
    Politics
    Get short URL
    5164
    Subscribe

    US President Obama made a big mistake when he halted cooperation with Russia on Syria, US journalist James W. Carden notes, warning that a military solution or an imposition of "no-fly zones" in Syria is "not the way forward."

    US President Barack Obama and his advisors have made a potentially grave mistake by suspending talks with the Russians over Syria, James W. Carden, the executive editor for the American Committee for East-West Accord's EastWestAccord.com, underscored in his article for The Nation.

    The journalist noted, however, that the Obama administration's decision to halt the US-Russian collaboration on Syria comes as no surprise. The ink had barely dried on the Syrian ceasefire deal when the Pentagon's officials openly signaled that they were not quite sure whether or not they would obey by the accords.

    Carden called attention to the fact that even US Secretary of State John Kerry, whom many regarded as a"dove," turned out to be a proponent of the military solution in Syria.

    "Former general and CIA director David Petraeus, no doubt echoing the establishment consensus on these issues, told Charlie Rose last week that establishing these zones would be 'very, very straightforward' and could be achieved 'very, very quickly'," the US journalist continued.

    However, several days ago Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Joseph Dunford told the Senate Armed Services Committee that a "no-fly zone" would obviously lead to war with Russia and Syria, Dave Majumdar of The National Interest noted in his recent op-ed.

    "Right now, Senator, for us to control all of the airspace in Syria it would require us to go to war against Syria and Russia. That's a pretty fundamental decision that certainly I'm not going to make," Dunford said, as quoted by Majumdar.

    Carden underscored that the much discussed "no-fly zone" in Syria evokes strong memories of "a similar operation over Kosovo (which resulted in a bombing campaign that lasted 78 days) or of the more recent imposition of a no-fly zone over Libya."

    He drew historic parallels between the US' Syrian policy and Washington's foreign policy strategy toward Vietnam. Carden underscored that then President Lyndon Johnson dragged the US into the long and exhausting war. Likewise Barack Obama is teetering on the balance of a new devastating conflict in Syria.

    "A military solution, and facile promises of easy answers like the imposition of no-fly and/or safe zones (which are neither easy nor answers) is not the way forward," Carden warned.

    "Obama and his advisers have made a potentially grave error in cutting off talks with the Russians, and even a cursory glance back through the history of recent American military interventions should steer them back to, not away from, the negotiating table," he underscored.

    Commenting on the White House's decision to halt the Russo-American cooperation, the Russian Foreign Ministry stressed Monday that the White House did almost everything to undermine trust between the US and Russia.

    "The Obama administration did everything to destroy the atmosphere of trust which could foster [bilateral] cooperation," the Foreign Ministry wrote in a statement.

    It also referred to the so-called Magnitsky Act that actually marked an era of "an unprecedented sanction pressure" on Russia "on far-fetched pretexts."

    During his Tuesday meeting with Saad Hariri, the leader of Lebanese political party Al-Mustaqbal, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov emphasized that "there were many who wanted to break up [the Syrian ceasefire agreement] from the beginning, including within the US administration."

    However, Lavrov stressed, Moscow believes that only through cooperation the international community may bring the Syrian war to an end.

    "We do not shy away from our responsibilities, but we believe that only collectively, only together — including with the US and Europe and with all the key countries in the region — can this crisis be resolved," Lavrov said.

    Related:

    'Moscow Grows Disenchanted' With Idea of US-Russian Cooperation in Syria
    US-Russian Deal: 'DoD Openly Saying It May or May Not Obey Obama'
    US Military Builds a New Air Base in Northern Syria
    Direct Aggression by US in Syria to Lead to 'Tectonic Shifts' in Middle East
    Tags:
    Syrian ceasefire, no-fly zone, safe zones, buffer zone, moderate Syrian rebels, air strikes, The Syrian war, U.S. Department of State, Pentagon, Lyndon B. Johnson, Joseph Dunford, John Kerry, Barack Obama, Sergei Lavrov, Libya, Syria, United States, Russia, Middle East, Vietnam, Kosovo
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik