04:51 GMT26 February 2021
Listen Live
    Get short URL

    The Russo-Israeli relationship has become especially cordial in recent years, CIA veteran Paul R. Pillar notes. But what lies at the root of Tel Aviv's shift to Moscow?

    The recent Russo-Israeli rapprochement has become the focus of Washington's attention. CIA veteran and the Brookings Institution's non-resident fellow Paul R. Pillar explains that since the Israeli-Russian relationship is not encumbered by special expectations — either positive or negative —  the countries have a space to maneuver.

    In contrast, "the US-Israeli relationship carries a very strong expectation, especially within domestic US politics, that the relationship is and ought to be one of strong and unshakable friendship. Any apparent deviation from that expectation is treated as if it were a serious problem," Pillar remarks in his opinion piece for the National Interest.

    It is no secret that Washington's relationship with Tel Aviv has recently deteriorated, not to mention the chill between the White House and the Kremlin.

    Pillar quotes Robert Danin, senior fellow for Middle East studies at the Council on Foreign Relations, who noted in his latest article for Foreign Affairs magazine that Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu and Russian President Putin "clearly enjoy a better relationship with each other than either does with US President Barack Obama."

    Curiously enough, while Washington demonstrates its belligerent stance toward Crimea's reunification with Russia and Moscow's backing Syrian legitimate leader Bashar al-Assad, Tel Aviv has adopted a pragmatic approach to the matters.

    Pillar refers to the fact that Israel abstained from the US-led effort to isolate Russia at the UN over the Crimean issue, thus distancing itself from Washington's policy in Ukraine.

    Furthermore, in contrast to Washington, the Netanyahu government is not actually interested in ousting Syrian President Bashar al-Assad:  "Israel enjoyed many years of quiet on the Golan front with the Assads in power, which is something it cannot expect with almost any possible alternative outcome of the war," the CIA veteran emphasizes.

    While US-Israeli relations are bursting at the seams over the Iranian nuclear deal, Tel Aviv voices no concerns regarding Russo-Iranian and Russo-Syrian cooperation.

    Moreover, Israel and Russia are bolstering security ties: "Netanyahu and Putin now have a secure hot line between their offices," Pillar notes, adding that Tel Aviv is selling advanced military technologies to Russia.

    Analysts point to the fact that Tel Aviv regards Russia as a serious geopolitical player in the Middle East.

    "You can hardly blame the Israeli government for looking north to the Russian Federation for a partnership with the new sheriff in town," Washington Times columnist L. Todd Wood wrote in early June.

    "Israel can no longer count on the United States for its ultimate security. America is no longer the protector of last resort," he added.

    At the same time, according to Dan Williams and Denis Dyomkin of Reuters, Russia has recently become "the closest thing to a guarantor" that Tel Aviv's "most potent enemies" — Iran and Syria — would restrain themselves from attacking Israel.

    Iranian newspaper Khorasan echoes the journalists, pointing out that "some analysts say that Russia's engagement in Syria helps in fact to maintain Israel's security. It has also allowed Tel Aviv to refrain from launching an unnecessary military campaign [in Syria]."

    In addition, there is an emotional factor that could influence the relationship between Russia and Israel: hundreds of thousands of Russian Jews are living in the Middle Eastern country.

    However, according to Pillar, there is even more to that matter than meets the eye.

    Citing Anna Borshchevskaya of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, the CIA veteran suggests that "the Russian and Israeli leaders share an interest in jointly sticking a finger in the eye of the United States."

    "This sort of situation, in which two states team up to frustrate and oppose a third, is one instance of exercising what realists would call a balance of power," he concludes.


    Netanyahu: Close Relations With Russia Benefit Israeli National Security
    Shining Example: Russia's Syrian Campaign as a 'Model' for Washington
    Washington's 'Objective in Syria Since War Began is to Remove Assad'
    Middle East, US foreign policy, cooperation, The Syrian war, NATO, Pentagon, Bashar al-Assad, Vladimir Putin, Barack Obama, Iran, Israel, Crimea, Syria, US, Ukraine, Russia
    Community standardsDiscussion