15:15 GMT +326 September 2016
Live
Syria's General Fahd Jassem al-Freij (C), Deputy Commander-in-Chief of the Army and the Armed Forces and Minister of Defense allegedly visiting troops in the northern Syrian city of Aleppo. (File)

The Aleppo Pocket: Turkey Running Out of Time for Its Plans to Invade Syria

© AFP 2016/ SANA
Military & Intelligence
Get short URL
72256421414

The Syrian Army has made major advances in Aleppo province, and is on the brink of surrounding the militant-held portion of the city of Aleppo, cutting off trade routes between the jihadists, Turkey and Daesh to boot. Now, Expert magazine suggests, Turkey's hints at intervention signal that the Ankara-backed militants are running out of time.

The northern Syrian city of Aleppo is the country's second city (and before the war in Syria began, its largest). In the last few months, the situation in the city, contested by government and rebel forces, has turned 180 degrees. 

Backed by Russian aviation, the Syrian Army first managed to reopen the roads to the government-held sections of the city, and then, earlier this month, to cut the road links to the rebel held portion, "effectively cutting off the rebels there," Sputnik columnist Alexander Mercouris has explained.

"The Syrian army's success," the columnist noted, "has been made all the greater because at the start of January the rebels sent reinforcements to Aleppo to resist what they expected would be a government offensive there. Now those reinforcements, together with the rebel fighters previously in the city, are encircled and trapped."

Moving forward, as the Syrian Army and allied local militias, plus Syrian Kurdish forces in the country's north, move to take control of the Syrian-Turkish border, and to cut off the rebels' supply routes with both Turkey to the north and the Daesh terrorists to the east, the regional operation is turning out to have implications for the entire Syrian theater. This, in turn, "has given impetus to all sorts of geopolitical tremors," military analyst and Expert magazine contributor Pyotr Skarabahaty explains.

In a detailed analysis of the situation on the ground, the journalist suggests that the Aleppo operation has already had major political implications for the region, leading to the so-called 'moderate' Islamists walking out on the Geneva peace talks, to a reassessment of the situation by Washington, and to a new narrative in Western media "about tens of thousands of Syrian civilians fleeing evil Russian bombs."

"The situation is changing almost every day," Skarabahaty writes, "but so far [Damascus and Moscow have] the strategic initiative, interfering with regional and Western powers ability to facilitate an appropriate response" to reinforce the jihadists.

The Balance of Forces in Syria: Legend: (Pink) Government Forces; (Grey) Daesh; (Aquamarine) Kurds; (Green) Militants; (White) Desert; (Yellow Stripes) Activity of Turkish Forces. (Ship) Logistical Support Point of the Russian Navy; (Plane) Russian Air Base; (Red Arrow) Direction of Syrian Army Offensives (Blue Arrow) Direction of Kurdish Offensives; (Downed Plane) Location of the Turkish-Downed Su-24; (Black Plane Outline) Possible Russian Air Base; (Blue Plane Outline) Possible US Air Base
"The Balance of Forces in Syria": Legend: (Pink) Government Forces; (Grey) Daesh; (Aquamarine) Kurds; (Green) Militants; (White) Desert; (Yellow Stripes) Activity of Turkish Forces. (Ship) Logistical Support Point of the Russian Navy; (Plane) Russian Air Base; (Red Arrow) Direction of Syrian Army Offensives (Blue Arrow) Direction of Kurdish Offensives; (Downed Plane) Location of the Turkish-Downed Su-24; (Black Plane Outline) Possible Russian Air Base; (Blue Plane Outline) Possible US Air Base

"The Syrian Arab Army (the SAA)," the journalist explains, "still does not have enough forces for a massive offensive on all fronts, and Russian aviation's participation too, is limited. Therefore, while Assad's forces and allied militias press against the militants in one part of the country (until recently – in Latakia, and in the province of Daraa to the south), in others they accrue their strength. Intense preparations for the operations outside Aleppo were conducted over several weeks, featuring the massing of infantry and mechanized units, including missile systems, rocket launchers and Russian-delivered T-90s with trained crews."

"But where exactly the [Syrian and Russian] allies would strike was unclear, and this was extremely unnerving to the extremists – after all, there were many possibilities. However, in hindsight we can say that the united General Staff has not deviated from the general line: the main task of the first phase of the operation is to close the Syrian border with Turkey and with Jordan, through which arms and jihadist volunteers flow into the country."

"Damascus struck to Aleppo's northwest toward the Shiite enclave cities of Nubl and Zahraa, which for over four years had been surrounded by the jihadists. In this operation, a new SAA tactic stood out: to bypass well-fortified positions, to search for weak spots in the area, and drive a mechanized wedge into the area following softening up by artillery and air power. Then, the army returns to the fortified area, but from the rear. In a few days, dozens of settlements were captured, and the land bridge was reinforced from counterattacks."

"The advance," Skarabahaty recalled, "was supported by the so-called 'Afrin' Kurds of the northwestern Kurdish Syrian canton and city of Afrin. Judging by the nature of the interaction and active assistance to the Kurds from Russian air power, this coalition was not formed by chance, but was successfully coordinated by the Russian general staff. As a result, the Kurdish forces took control of a number of cities, in spite of their difficult relations with the regular army, and organized joint patrols and checkpoints."

"Here in general, we can complement [Russia's] military planners, who had been planning for the Syrian operation over the past six months," the journalist noted. "Their efforts remain invisible to the layman, but are critical to success and the minimization of losses on the front."

"It's difficult to imagine how much effort has been expended to create a single operational plan ensuring cooperation between the motley crew of the pro-Assad coalition, featuring Lebanese, Iraqi, Iranian, Syrian, and Kurdish militias and armies, Shiites and Sunnis, different national groups, units with varying degrees of training, experience and equipment, not to mention logistics, and transport. The high level of professionalism of Russian military advisors is clear."

This week, Skarabahaty  noted, "the SAA and the Kurdish militia are continuing their push to expand the corridor to the south and to the north, although the speed of this effort has slowed significantly in favor of strengthening what has already been secured."

"The jihadist districts of Aleppo have come under threat, previously fighting it out for months with army units in difficult conditions featuring a dense concentration of buildings and underground tunnels."

Importantly, Skarabahaty says, "the army is obviously moving in the direction of the north toward the Turkish border. Here, the Islamists quickly strengthen their southern approaches and receive reinforcements from Turkey. The army's ultimate goal is to take the border 'under lock and key'; this is a major factor geopolitically, causing a sharp anxiety among Ankara and its allies."

"What's so important about this corridor for the anti-Assad front? First, as has already been said, it is here that weapons and militants make their way to Syria, and in large quantities. Of course, Idlib province (to Aleppo's southwest) has a much longer border with Turkey; therefore speaking of the situation as a 'pocket' is not entirely appropriate. The essence is in the convenience of logistics. It is Aleppo province which features wide highways, established border crossings and smuggling routes. And the portion of the city of Aleppo which is not controlled by Damascus serves as a major logistics hub for the flow of terrorists to other areas. The Idlib border is much less convenient, with mountain ranges making it impossible to pass large parties [of weapons, of fighters] through."  

​"But no less important," the analyst notes, "is the logistics route which once passed through the area – through which an active trade [of food and oil] took place between the jihadists and Daesh."

"The agreements, concluded with Ankara's participation, provided for Daesh oil to be transported to the northern Syrian province, in exchange for food. In this way, for both sides, the trade route literally served as a 'lifeline', because the territory under Daesh's control consists mainly of oil fields, while pro-Turkish groups occupy relatively fertile land, but without energy deposits and processing facilities."

The Syrian operation to cut off this trade route, Skarabahaty writes, "has already led to warnings from journalists in the jihadist-controlled areas of Idlib and Aleppo provinces about the difficult situation on the ground: without fuel supplies, food plants running on diesel generators have stopped, as have transport and the service industry; light and electricity, dependent on the same generators, has also been cut. But what they remain silent about is that the jihadists' military equipment has also been put on a starvation diet of fuel."

At the same time, with 50,000 refugees fleeing for Turkey in connection with the Syrian offensive, "Ankara," the journalist warns, "is sounding the alarm and calling on the whole world to pay attention to the crisis which it says was 'triggered by the Russian air strikes'. Border crossings have been closed, crowds accumulate and a picture of a 'humanitarian apocalypse' is being presented in the Western media."

"It seems," Skarabahaty continues, "that this card will soon be played by Ankara and the West to put pressure on the Syrian-Russian coalition – and perhaps serve as a pretext for a ground invasion."

Syrian government forces inspect an area near the village of Khan Tuman, south from the provincial capital Aleppo, on December 22, 2015
© AFP 2016/ GEORGE OURFALIAN
The reality, the journalist suggests, Turkey's refusal to allow a Russian observation flight over Turkey last week under the Open Skies Treaty signals that Russia fully understands what Ankara is up to. 

"The fact is that Russian specialists had deliberately proposed a flight path to their foreign colleagues indicating that the nature of Ankara's plans is absolutely clear to the Russian General Staff, and that the reaction to follow may be extremely tough."

Last week, citing Syrian images showing Turkish self-propelled artillery units on the Syrian border, Defense Ministry spokesman Maj. Gen. Igor Konashenkov stressed that Russia "considers Turkey's move as a dangerous precedent and an attempt to hide its illegal military activity on the border with Syria."

Meanwhile, Skarabahaty explains, from Ankara's point of view, the task of "creating a buffer zone on its southern borders is a task of paramount importance; the question which arises is whether the zone will be located on Turkish or Syrian territory. With Russia's entry into the conflict, hopes of overthrowing the Syrian government have vanished; Ankara had relied on jihadists under its control, but has now been forced to set up blocking detachments to prevent militants fleeing from Russian air strikes coming back into Turkey."

"The other uses for the buffer zone include keeping the Kurdish offensive at a distance, preventing the two Kurdish enclaves in northwest and northeast Syria from uniting. Finally, a hypothetical zone of influence is important for trading with Daesh and supplying it with fighters."

"The Russian warning," via the proposed overflight, Skarabahaty argues, "has held back the Turkish initiative, but has not resolved the problem: With each new territory in northern Aleppo taken by government forces and their allies, the less time Turkey has left to intervene on Syrian territory. Because it is one thing to seize territory controlled by the militants, and quite another to get involved in a fight with the SAA or the Kurds, the latter actively cooperating with the US."

"The choice can be put as follows: whether Turkey is ready to act unilaterally with the tacit support of the West, or agree on an initiative to align with the US coalition."

Unfortunately, with the Erdogan government effectively blackmailing Brussels by threatening to 'dump' its refugees on Europe, "the EU may decide to close its eyes on a Turkish military operation, as it has already done with the growing carnage in the Kurdish areas of Turkey." The German chancellor's remarks on being 'shocked by the suffering of tens of thousands' due to Russian airstrikes indicates that "she is willing to play this game," Skarabahaty noted.

Ultimately, the analyst argues, "it's important to understand that a Turkish intervention would not mean a direct military confrontation between Turkey and Russia. It's very likely, [instead], that we will see another episode of a hybrid war; and it cannot be excluded that, hardened by four years of war, Assad's forces, equipped with Russian tanks, will be able to rebuff the Turks." 

After all, as official Damascus has already warned, "any military intervention without the Syrian government's consent will be perceived as aggression. In this connection, invaders will have to be sent home in coffins."

At the same time, Skarabahaty warned that the danger stemming from the US's off-again on-again, befuddled policy with regard to the conflict in Syria should not be discounted. In any case, Washington's alliance of convenience with the Kurds, and its growing ideational conflict with Ankara have complicated things; the question is whether the US is willing to abandon the Kurds in favor of Ankara and Erdogan.

Related:
Syrian Army Attacks Militants in Latakia, Recapturing Town of Bashoura
'It’s a Power Game': Erdogan’s Ultimatum to Washington Decoded
The Syrian Army is Not Attacking Aleppo But Defending It
Tags:
plans, invasion, military operation, Idlib, Aleppo, Syria, Turkey
Community standardsDiscussion
Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik
  • Сomment
  • Ann in reply toFlorianGeyer(Show commentHide comment)
    FlorianGeyer, The 'Muricans had no choice, you see, they can't see around their inflated egos.
  • michaelin reply toAnn (Show commentHide comment)
    sixpack6t9, yes, I saw that this morning on the bbc.
  • michaelin reply toIs it because I am black?(Show commentHide comment)
    Is it because I am black?, that's an interesting bit of information. Thanks. :)
  • michaelin reply toAnn (Show commentHide comment)
    sixpack6t9, as each day goes by and I find out more about nato's actions and history, I agree that they should be prosecuted for war crimes.
  • cmat.wolfgang
    Yes, that's true:
    "The German chancellor's remarks on being 'shocked by the suffering of tens of thousands' due to Russian airstrikes indicates that "she is willing to play this game," Skarabahaty noted."
    The anti-Assad and anti-Russia propaganda machine (with the Agitprop expert Merkle) already started in Germany! The criminal forced taxes media (GEZ) every German has to pay even when he does not use them, is touting the government Position. But most intelligent People who I know judge those media like the Goebbels News.
  • goaisminein reply toarmor(Show commentHide comment)
    armor, don't worry the only one that could spoil the issue
    but turkey knows very well such a adventure would only give
    Russia full task to shoot down a few Turkey Jet Fighters within Syrian Air Space and should the US step in then we are all marching torwards
    a desaster !
  • goaisminein reply to (Show commentHide comment)
    misterno1, that's correct but their options are being narrowed down
    day by day so only option would be a full-fledged-invasion but
    i rather not tell you what that means !
  • goaisminein reply toMother Gorilla(Show commentHide comment)
    Mother Gorilla, Depends but right now the Kurdish-Para-Military-Groups
    are watching if Russa and Syria is paving the way for further occupation
    of Syrian Soil - But don't worry the Kurds will not get their mini-kurdistan
    within mother syria ! Syrian Goverment is fully aware of such Kurdish-Plots
    supported by the US-Agents
  • FlorianGeyerin reply toAnn (Show commentHide comment)
    sixpack6t9,

    Many Americans cannot see their shoes when they attempt to tie their shoelaces up as well.
  • Mother Gorillain reply togoaismine(Show commentHide comment)
    goaismine, I am not worried about that, the Kurds need a bigger state, but this time it needn't be the American idea of a reorganisation.
  • goaisminein reply toMother Gorilla(Show commentHide comment)
    Mother Gorilla, " Kurds need a bigger state " the Kurds have had never a state
    and they will never get a state at least not in the boundaries of Mother Land Syria - if the Kurds want a state for themself they can move to Turkey or North-Iraq but not within Syria ! The Kurds are working hand in hand with the US-WarCrimnals to establish Mini-Kurdistan within the Borders of Syria
    this will never happend ! Syria is and will be the motherland of the Syrian
    do the Kurds really think once we join the US we will get our " Save-Heaven "
    along the Turkish-Border - Well if they attack the Syrian Army then they will be hunted down just like the US/EU/NATO-Imported Terrorists
    viva syria !
  • Is it because I am black?in reply togoaismine(Show commentHide comment)
    goaismine, no, they have their own point of view, which is mainly anti-Turk, but also much more left-wing than the mainstream in Turkey and very anti-US. I know them from their rallies.

    They have a lot of land that they would finally like to be recognised as theirs, in that, there are certainly not alone on this earth.

    I can see that you are probably very pro-Syrian, but definitely, the Kurds have been playing a more constructive role in this conflict than Turkey and the whole of the West and also working well with the Russians.

    You shouldn't equate them with ISIS!
  • goaisminein reply toIs it because I am black?(Show commentHide comment)
    Is it because I am black?, You shouldn't equate them with ISIS!
    I don*t but i know by alot of friends on the ground that the Kursish-Militaria-Groups have worked hand in hand since the Beginning with the FAKE FSA = FREE SYRIAN ARMY and even in Kobani also hand in hand with the FSA and US - the main strategy that the US followed since the Beginning is to fragment Mother Syria this will never happend . Our Brothers and Sisters
    witch are daily on the fronts are not fighting for any kind of MINI-KURDISTAN
    within the Syrian Motherland - They shall know if they think they can establish such a plot within Syria then the Syrian Army will hunt them down
    just like those US/EU/NATO-imported Filth ! and btw the ISIL is a creation of the US witch is used for such filthy plots ! Kurds within Syria yes but no MINI-STATE and all resources will be back in the hands of our Heros!
  • Is it because I am black?in reply togoaismine(Show commentHide comment)
    goaismine, yes, that ISIS is a creation of US and Co., I read that, here on this site and elsewhere, but I was unaware that the Kurds were playing such a treacherous role. In Germany, where there is a huge Kurdish population, they are often considered heros, because they withstand Turkish imperialism and human rights abuse.
  • Is it because I am black?in reply togoaismine(Show commentHide comment)
    goaismine, Good luck in our struggle for a free Syria!
  • Ann in reply toFlorianGeyer(Show commentHide comment)
    FlorianGeyer, I couldn't either - but only because I was very pregnant.
  • slimyfoxin reply togoaismine(Show commentHide comment)
    goaismine, Your amassment of the situation is correct, only that you forgot to mention that situation is not that clear with regard occupation of land as USA are actively preparing an airfield in Kurdish NE area close to Turkish Border.
    If USA puts the boots on the ground that might start to complicate the situation in absolutely every direction, not just for Syria and allays but for USA as well. That can become ignition point for major conflict between major powers. USA are desperate to arrange gas and oil pipeline from Gulf States to EU thus banning EU from using Russian oil and gas hoping that financial crisis will crack Russia and bring new Gorbachev or Yeltsin which would allow them to dissect Russia to the smallest peaces.
    Situation is not clear at all, and only speedy and decisive securing borders with Turkey and Jordan will put an end on these wet dreams. There is another option which is that Russia builds air base in the same region as Kurds would welcome it more than American.
  • Mother Gorilla
    Not to worry, Turkey, there is still lots of time to invade after a new warmonger gets into the White House!
  • Ivan Buckeye
    Tricky. These choices sort of force the west to show its hand. Abandon the Kurds and Russia will surely win them all over in whatever country. Stick with Turkey, again, must abandon the Kurds. Losing Turkey or having to weaken Turkey is not the greatest choice either. Ha. This is a way to flush out any further games and bring on the next stage of stability. Too funny the American officials are now forced to make a decision. Good move .
  • pbecke
    "It's difficult to imagine how much effort has been expended to create a single operational plan ensuring cooperation between the motley crew of the pro-Assad coalition, featuring Lebanese, Iraqi, Iranian, Syrian, and Kurdish militias and armies, Shiites and Sunnis, different national groups, units with varying degrees of training, experience and equipment, not to mention logistics, and transport. The high level of professionalism of Russian military advisors is clear."

    I suspect this manifest ability of the Russians to create synergies in the normally chaotic world of warfare, in contrast to the West's, but particularly America's, national domestic tradition of cut-throat, dog-eat-dog anomie, is what scares its military leaders.

    The respect the Russians would be showing to their potential allies on both racial and personal levels both would have engendered their smooth cooperation, boosted by its life-saving diplomacy and destructive abilities in battle. They stand for reason and law.

    The military commanders of the Allies may or may not be as smart as those of the Russians, but they must be fearful, consciously or subliminally, of a markedly inferior coordination of the troops of the NATO countries in tacking the Russians in Europe, as well, should they themselves start a war with them.

    But for the extraordinary advantage of their enemies being without assistance from the air, one might reasonably suggest that so far, the Russians have created something possibly unique in the annals of war : a falsification of historian, Barbara Tuchman's normally iron-clad rule, to the effect that war is the unfolding of miscalculations.
Show new comments (0)
Top stories