18:46 GMT +323 October 2019
Listen Live
    Notre Dame Cathedral on fire, Paris

    Guardian Jumps on Claim Sputnik Edited Notre Dame Fire Photo Despite Disproof

    © Sputnik /
    Europe
    Get short URL
    6293
    Subscribe

    Sputnik France's editorial team has released the original of the photo in question with full metadata, prompting several fact checking sites to acknowledge its authenticity. However, the Guardian has become the last but not least of the publications that picked up on the allegations regardless.

    Over the weekend, Sputnik France's photo of the Notre Dame blaze made its way into 'Fake or for Real', The Guardian's Instagram story series about what's true and what's false in today's media reports.

    The photo of the burning cathedral, taken from a distance, also shows two men smiling in the forefront − and that's pretty much it. The image first emerged during Sputnik France's live web coverage of the Notre Dame incident and was first published on SF's social media and the website without a company logo or a watermark.

    'Fake or for Real', The Guardian's Instagram story series
    'Fake or for Real', The Guardian's Instagram story series

    The picture fast spread on to the social media, with some bloggers assuming that the two were Muslims and some right-wing activists going on to claim that 'Muslims were celebrating the tragedy'.

    'Fake or for Real', The Guardian's Instagram story series
    'Fake or for Real', The Guardian's Instagram story series

    The controversy then made its way to PolitiFact, a US-based fact-checking project, who claimed, citing forensic experts from the University of Colorado Denver, that the two men in question had been inserted in the photo, apparently in a bid to push forward an Islamophobic narrative.

    'Fake or for Real', The Guardian's Instagram story series
    'Fake or for Real', The Guardian's Instagram story series

    While Sputnik France commented on the grievous allegations and the website's chief editor Natalia Novikova calling for responsibility in journalism, the outlet has also put the original photo on a cloud storage where the metadata indicating when and how the pictures were made can be accessed after downloading the image (click here to access).

    READ MORE: Oh, the Irony: Fake Watchers Make False Claim About Sputnik's 'Fake News'

    Several news outlets and fact-checkers have since updated their stories. However, at the time of the publication, the Guardian has not issued any corrections.

    Related:

    Process of Rain Protection Installation Over France's Damaged Notre Dame (VIDEO)
    France Appreciates Russia's Offer to Help Rebuild Notre Dame - Envoy
    Architects Respond to International Call to Design New Notre Dame Spire
    Investigators Believe Notre Dame Blaze Started at Base of Iconic Spire - Reports
    Notre Dame Bees Reportedly Survive as Devastating Fire Made Insects 'DRUNK'
    Tags:
    fake news, Notre Dame Cathedral, fire, Muslims, terrorism, The Guardian, France
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik