11:17 GMT +320 July 2019
Listen Live
    French soldiers patrol in front of the Eiffel Tower

    France Accused of 'Disproportionate' Use of Emergency Powers

    © AFP 2019 / BERTRAND GUAY
    Europe
    Get short URL
    0 64

    Human rights groups claim that the use of emergency powers in France, following a series of terrorist attacks has led to "disproportionate and unnecessary restrictions of the right to freedom of assembly" in violation of the French motto "liberte egalite fraternite."

    According to a new report from Amnesty International, in 2016, the French authorities banned dozens of public assemblies using emergency powers and placed restrictions on hundreds of individuals to prevent them from exercising their right to freedom of assembly.

    ​"Individuals not linked in any way to acts of terrorism are getting caught in the cross-hairs of the emergency measures. This report shows the disproportionate use of emergency powers to restrict the right to freedom of assembly in situations unrelated to any specific threat of attacks on the general population. Moreover, the report shows that French authorities often relied on unnecessarily resource-intensive strategies and used force disproportionately when policing public assemblies," Amnesty said. 

    Between 14 November 2015, when the French government declared a state of emergency, and 5 May 2017, prefects issued 155 measures banning public assemblies using the additional powers conferred on them by the state of emergency. On numerous occasions, they also banned or imposed wide-ranging restrictions on public assemblies by resorting to their ordinary powers.

    ​"There are concerns as to whether such broad and sweeping measures and the restrictions they imposed on the right to freedom of peaceful assembly were necessary and proportionate in pursuit of the legitimate aim of maintaining public order. More generally, Amnesty International is concerned by the use of emergency powers to impose restrictions on human rights which did not appear to be strictly required by the exigencies of the situation," the report said.

    "The European Court of Human Rights (European Court) has on numerous occasions affirmed that the right to freedom of peaceful assembly covers meetings on public thoroughfares and in enclosed places or privately owned premises, as well as both static meetings and public processions. It is a right that can be exercised both by individual participants and by those organizing the assembly," Amnesty said.

    Under French law, the police officials or mayors responsible for receiving notification of a public assembly can issue a decree banning a particular public assembly if they consider it is likely to disrupt public order.

    A photo taken on November 17, 2015 in Paris shows the Eiffel Tower illuminated with the colors of the French national flag in tribute to the victims of the November 13 Paris terror attacks.
    © AFP 2019 / Bertrand Guay
    A photo taken on November 17, 2015 in Paris shows the Eiffel Tower illuminated with the colors of the French national flag in tribute to the victims of the November 13 Paris terror attacks.

    According to Amnesty, under the state of emergency currently in force, prefects can ban public assemblies on vaguely formulated grounds. They can ban, for example, public assemblies in enclosed or privately owned venues (reunions) on the grounds that they are likely to "provoke or encourage disorder." They can also restrict the movement of persons in specific areas with the effect of preventing public assemblies.

    Amnesty International is calling on the French authorities to use their powers to ban public assemblies only as a measure of last resort. They must ensure that any prohibition complies with the criteria of necessity and proportionality set out in international human rights law.

    Related:

    Terror Threat Level Remains 'Very High' in France - Prime Minister
    'All Is Not Done': Terror Takes Center Stage as France Prepares for Election
    Russian Parliament Calls on France to Take Part in Anti-Terror Coalition
    France Charges Brussels Bombing Suspect Over Paris Terror Attacks
    Tags:
    public assembly, emergency powers, terror threat, terror, emergency, terrorism, human rights, protests, ban, security, Nice Truck Attack, November 13, 2015 Paris terrorist attacks, European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), Amnesty International, Francois Hollande, Europe, Paris, Nice, France
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik