11:09 GMT +328 March 2017

    Edward Snowden Testimony in Germany Would Be a 'Disappointment' - Spy Chief

    © Photo: Pixabay
    Get short URL

    Legal attempts to allow former CIA contractor Edward Snowden to give testimony in Berlin over Germany's involvement in mass surveillance programs by the US and Britain are likely to lead to disappointment," according to the head of Germany's intel agency BND.

    The German parliament has set up an inquiry into the role played by the German BND spy agency in the mass surveillance programs, outlined by Snowden in 2013, run by the US National Security Agency (NSA) and Britain's General Communications Headquarters (GCHQ).

    Attempts to bring Snowden before the inquiry committee have — so far — proved fruitless, because of opposition from the German Government. However, the German Federal Court of Justice. November 21, ruled — in response to a request from opposition parties the Greens and the Left — that the Berlin administration were obliged to invite Snowden to give evidence.

    The issue of whether Snowden would actually leave Moscow — where he is in temporary asylum — is unclear, although it is highly unlikely he would risk leaving the sanctuary of Russia to venture to Germany, which is a strong US ally, putting him in danger of extradition to the US (and possible execution).

    US-German Ties

    Despite the apparent breakthrough, the President of the BND, Gerhard Schindler has told the Berliner Zeitung newspaper that the committee of politicians are not likely to gain new insights. "If Snowden is actually to be heard as a witness, you will be disappointed," Schindler said.

    President of the German Federal Intelligence Agency (BND) Gerhard Schindler stands at the former monitoring base of the National Security Agency (NSA) in Bad Aibling, south of Munich, June 6, 2014.
    © REUTERS/ Michaela Rehle
    President of the German Federal Intelligence Agency (BND) Gerhard Schindler stands at the former monitoring base of the National Security Agency (NSA) in Bad Aibling, south of Munich, June 6, 2014.

    The German Government came in for enormous criticism after it was revealed that its own government — in the form of Chancellor Angela Merkel's office — had been aware of the close cooperation between Germany's BND and the NSA in surveillance of politicians and commercial companies on German soil.

    Merkel's government had previously reacted with anger at the Snowden revelations of mass surveillance by the NSA and GCHQ in Europe — including, allegedly, Merkel's own phone. When it was revealed that the BND was working in cahoots with the NSA, the issue became politically toxic, leading to the current parliamentary inquiry.

    Schindler' comments — as the BND's chief — that Snowden's evidence will be effectively pointless will add fuel to the fire suggesting the German Government is more interested in maintaining close links with Washington that raking over old coals.


    Turkey 'Not Easy Partner' for Germany Within NATO – Ex-BND Chief
    BND ‘Real Enemy’ of Germans for Sake of Partnership With NSA – Pirate Party
    German BND Reform Should Reduce Agency's Dependence on NSA – Lawmaker
    Snowden's Lawyer Says Whistleblower's Extradition to US 'Impossible'
    Obama: Pardon for Snowden Couldn’t Be Contemplated Until US Court Appearance
    bulk collection, spying, mass surveillance, snooping, German Federal Intelligence Service (BND), British Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ), National Security Agency (NSA), Angela Merkel, Edward Snowden, Germany, Moscow, United States, Russia, United Kingdom, Berlin
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik
    • Сomment

    All comments

    • avatar
      Sure it will lead to disappointment since he would reveal their hypocrisy!
    • avatar
      they all know just what they got up to
      his testimony would open it to public scrutiny
      what they fear the most
      until Trumps in office Snowdens not safe
      nor is Assange
      and even then...the mil section and the alphabet agencies still have a lot they want hidden.
    Show new comments (0)