01:53 GMT05 December 2020
Listen Live
    Get short URL

    Infamous Ukrainian lawmaker Alexei Goncharenko, a member of the Petro Poroshenko Bloc parliamentary faction, has called on the government to study the experience of state building used by the Swiss Confederation. Unfortunately, Ukrainian politics experts suggest that Bosnia, not Switzerland, may be the more relevant model for contemporary Ukraine.

    Goncharenko, who has been accused in Russia of helping to organize the violent events  of May 2, 2014, when far-right activists in Odessa, Ukraine blocked anti-Maidan protesters inside the city's House of Trade Unions and set it on fire, killing 48 people, made his comments about 'studying' Switzerland's model on the occasion of Swiss National Day, which commemorates the foundation of the state, on August 1.

    "There is no other country in the world where the beauty of nature is so harmoniously complemented by the beauty of the country's social order," the politician wrote. "26 independent regional associations, speaking four languages, constitute one of the most sound nations in the world. I think you will agree, this is an example worth emulating," the politician wrote, in a blog entry on the Ukrainskaya Pravda website.

    The lawmaker suggested that the issue of political decentralization "is a question of crucial importance for Ukraine today. The Swiss experience of coexistence with multilingual people from multiple cultures united by the ideas of peace, social and economic freedoms is deserves a full investigation and accurate implementation in our country."

    Commenting on Goncharenko's proposals, Russian online newspaper Svobodnaya Pressa columnist Dmitri Rodionov recalled that the political activist's proposals are somewhat odd, given that Goncharenko "became famous for violent attacks on supporters of federalization in Odessa, [those calling for the] autonomy of Bessarabia, and [those pushing] Russian-Ukrainian bilingualism initiatives."

    Furthermore, Rodionov added, "it is also worth noting that President Petro Poroshenko, and his parliamentary bloc, to which Mr. Goncharenko belongs, have from the beginning of their term in office been in favor of the country's unitary structure and categorically against federalization."

    In fact, "the word 'federalization' is virtually taboo, and those who speak about its necessity are usually categorized as 'separatists' and enemies of Ukraine. The charge of 'separatism' is brought even against the timid requests of local councils asking for the economic and cultural autonomy of the country's regions. In the same way, those who declare the need to make Russian the second state language are similarly categorized 'enemies'; the most radical among the nationalists even call the Russian language 'an instrument of occupation'."

    At the same time, the journalist suggested that "it's important to emphasize that the Swiss model with which deputy Goncharenko is so impressed with is not even a federation, but a confederation, consisting of 20 cantons and six half-cantons. Each canton has its own constitution, and its own powers, limited by the national constitution. The national government is given jurisdiction over the issues of war and peace, foreign relations, the army, railways, communications, the emission of money, the approval of the national budget, etc. The Swiss as a nation do not have one common language. The national and official languages of the confederation include German, French, Italian and Romansh."

    Asked to comment on Goncharenko's comments, and on whether Ukraine really can take a lesson from the Swiss confederacy's model of state organization, Alexander Vasilyev, a former representative on the Odessa City Council, said that unfortunately, this is highly unlikely.

    "Given the realities of today's Ukraine, I think that the experience of Switzerland is less applicable to our country than that of Bosnia. The latter is a territory in which a confederation was formed following a civil war; its legitimacy and sovereignty is entirely dependent on support from the Western powers."

    Furthermore, Vasilyev suggested that "the window of opportunity for Ukraine's reorganization [along federal lines] continues to shrink."

    "Before the war, I was among those who actively promoted Ukraine's consideration of the experience of successful federal states like Germany, Canada, and Switzerland. Now, as I've said, Bosnia has the most relevant experience for our country. But it seems that no one is any hurry to adopt even this variant."

    At the same time, Vasilyev warned that "if Ukraine refuses to learn from the experience of others in the coexistence of diverse cultural and ethnic groups, it will inevitably lead to its further disintegration."

    Effectively, he suggested that for him, "it makes no sense to talk about some single will of Ukraine as a country, looking for one or another path of development. If such a will existed, we would not be here discussing the experiences of Bosnia or Switzerland. One part of Ukraine wants into [the EU-based] Europe, another into Russia, and Ukraine itself is not needed by either of these groups. The nationalists in principle do not conceive of things rationally; their desire for European integration is like a religion – a kind of political sect, and one which is destructive."

    For his part, Russian-Ukrainian political commentator Viktor Shapinov suggested that the Swiss model could be applied if one cultural and linguistic group did not attempt to impose its will on others by force. "Unfortunately," he noted, "there are no forces in modern Ukraine that could put in force such a policy of consensus."


    Gang in Romania Smuggling Weapons From Ukraine to West. Europe, Mid. East
    Lugansk People's Republic Head Accuses Ukraine of Assassination Attempt
    Ukrainian MP Demands Kiev Provide Evidence of Russian Troops in Country's East
    Half of Asylum Seekers in Czech Republic in 2016 Come From Ukraine, Iraq
    Canada Sending 200 Troops to Ukraine to Continue Military Training
    Kiev Borrows $260Mln From US to Build Nuclear Waste Repository
    Trump: Crimean Citizens Want to Be With Russia, Not With Ukraine
    confederation, federalization, decentralization, Alexei Goncharenko, Bosnia, Ukraine, Switzerland
    Community standardsDiscussion