03:58 GMT +327 May 2019
Listen Live
    A CCTV (Closed Circuit Television) camera is seen against the backdrop of Big Ben in central London

    UK Lawmakers Blasted Over Snoopers' Charter Abstentions

    © AP Photo /
    Europe
    Get short URL
    0 73

    UK rights campaign group Privacy International has hit out at lawmakers in the UK House of Parliament for abstaining on a vote to amend the controversial Investigatory Powers draft bill despite many describing it as flawed, Sputnik has been told.

    The legislation — known as the Snoopers' Charter — is being put through parliament in the UK government's latest attempt to stem the criticism brought about after the revelations by ex-CIA Edward Snowden, who exposed mass surveillance and collection of data by the UK intelligence agency GCHQ and the US National Security Agency (NSA).

    Critics have said the draft legislation — in its current form — will allow police and the intelligence agencies to demand that communication services providers (CSPs) retain mass volumes of data on users' emails, browsing, social media use and mobile communication for up to 12 months.

    The proposed law will allow for the security services to demand 'back-door access' to their technology — a case reminiscent of the US FBI's current face-off with Apple over backdoor access to its phone technology.

    This will also allow a UK Secretary of State "fleixible" powers to demand access to communications data, the power to demand communications be routed via a certain electronic path and secrecy from the Communication Service Providers (CSPs).

    'Fantastically Intrusive'

    "Today's second reading debate was a missed opportunity to put a brake on new surveillance powers that fundamentally shift the balance of power between the individual and the state," Privacy International Director of Campaigns, Harmit Kambo told Sputnik.

    "The Labour Party and the Scottish National Party (SNP) strongly criticized many fundamental aspects of the Bill, but we are disappointed that both parties abstained from the vote.

    "We nonetheless welcome their calls for substantial amendments to the bill before they consider actually supporting the Government. The Shadow Home Secretary, Andy Burnham said the bill is 'not acceptable in its current form' and Joanna Cherry MP, the SNP Justice and Home Affairs spokesperson said that many of the powers are 'fantastically intrusive' and that the Bill, in its current form, is on a collision course with the European courts," she said.

    Introducing the Second Reading of the bill Tuesday, UK Home Secretary Theresa May said: "The Government are committed to updating and consolidating our country's investigatory powers in a clear and comprehensive new law that will stand the test of time. 

    "The revised Bill is clearer, with tighter technical definitions and strict codes of practice. It includes stronger privacy safeguards, bolstering protections for lawyers and journalists' sources; it explicitly prevents our agencies from asking foreign intelligence agencies to intercept the communications of a person in the UK on their behalf unless they have a warrant approved by a Secretary of State and a judicial commissioner," she said.

    The Labour Party home affairs spokesman Andy Burnham told the House of Commons:

    "I will not be joining the hon. Gentleman in the Lobby tonight [to vote on the bill]t, because I do not believe…  that the Bill is acceptable in its current form."

    The bill will continue through parliament despite both the Labour Party and the SNP abstaining, demanding substantial changes to the wording of the legislation.

    Related:

    Critics Slam UK Snoopers' Charter's Failure to Prevent Mass Surveillance
    UK Snoopers' Charter to Allow Police 'Backdoor' Access to Customer Data
    UN, Privacy Groups Slam UK Snoopers' Charter
    Eyes Down: Britain's Surveillance Law Revised, Spying Powers Extended
    Tags:
    MPs, spying, mass surveillance, snooping, legislation, intelligence, bill, draft, Scottish National Party, Labour Party, House of Commons, Theresa May, Great Britain, Europe, United Kingdom
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik