14:00 GMT +308 December 2019
Listen Live
    People taking a selfie in front of the Eiffel Tower, Paris.

    Facebook Takes Legal Blow in France as India Outlaws Its Free-Net Service

    © Flickr / Olivier Ortelpa
    Get short URL

    France's privacy authority has ordered that Facebook must stop collecting French users' information without their consent, and transferring data to the US.

    A decision published by the CNIL (French commission for information protection) underlined how Facebook's practice of tracking non-users' Internet activities without their consent failed to comply with EU privacy regulation.

    The CNIL also stated that Facebook's collection of data "concerning the sexual orientation, religious views and political opinions" of its users and the subsequent transfer to the US was in violation of the law. It added that the social network's password policy did not ensure maximum security to users. 

    The decision builds on a landmark EU ruling that last year struck down the Safe Harbor Pact, a transatlantic agreement that allowed American companies operating in Europe to send some information offshore. The verdict is thought to have been heavily influenced by Edward Snowden's revelation about US surveillance activities in Europe.

    A new pact has been negotiated to replace the defunct Safe Harbor, but it is not in force yet, and EU data protection authorities are still assessing its impact on transatlantic data transfer.

    Ahead of France's decision, Facebook had declared that it was in compliance with the EU regulation, and that it did not rely on Safe Harbor as the legal basis for moving data offshore.

    Now, France's decision will force Facebook to review its policies within three months.

    "Protecting the privacy of the people who use Facebook is at the heart of everything we do. We… look forward to engaging with the CNIL to respond to their concerns," a spokeswoman told Reuters.

    The Menlo Park-based company had already been ordered to stop tracking non-users by a Belgian court in 2015.

    The French blow hit Facebook just hours after India made the social network's free internet service illegal on net neutrality grounds.

    Facebook had been running "Free Basics", a plan to bring mobile Internet to the masses free of charge, since February 2015.

    The plan, touted as a way to give more opportunities to India's general population, had nonetheless been criticized by Internet activists because it would allow free access to only a few handpicked websites and apps — impinging on the principle that all websites should be accessible for the same price.

    Yesterday, India's Telecom Regulatory Authority, ruled that Internet providers cannot discriminate on pricing for different web services.

    "Everything on the Internet is agnostic in the sense that it cannot be priced differently," the authority chairman Ram Sevak Sharma said at a press conference.

    Facebook's free Internet service had already been temporarily disabled pending a decision.

    In a disappointed comment on his Facebook page, the company's CEO Mark Zuckerberg wrote: "Connecting India is an important goal we won't give up on, because more than a billion people in India don't have access to the Internet.

    We know that connecting them can help lift people out of poverty, create millions of jobs and spread education opportunities. We care about these people, and that's why we're so committed to connecting them."    


    EU-US Privacy Shield to Protect All Personal Data - EU Commission
    New Data Transfer Deal With EU Unable to Prevent US From Gathering Info
    European Data Watchdog Chief Slams EU-US Deal as 'Just Words'
    EU Surrenders to US, Tech Industry Lobbyists on Data Privacy Safeguards
    US Reluctant to Guarantee Full Data Privacy Rights to Europeans
    data sharing, Safe Harbor agreement, personal data, telecommunications, Messenger, data collection, social networks, law, NSA spying, surveillance, privacy, Internet, CNIL, Facebook, Mark Zuckerberg, India, Europe, France
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik