01:34 GMT +322 May 2019
Listen Live
    Court

    'This is Insane' - Journo Reacts to Verdict Victim 'Too Masculine' to Be Raped

    CC0
    Opinion
    Get short URL
    0 0 0

    Last week, reports emerged that two Peruvian men were cleared of rape charges after the judges agreed the woman of Peruvian origin who alleged she was a victim looked "too masculine" to be a sexual object. Sputnik discussed this with journalist Giulia Ausani.

    Sputnik: Do you think it's acceptable that one's lack of attractiveness could undermine their credibility as a rape victim?

    Giulia Ausani: No, it's not acceptable, because one's physical appearance and attractiveness (or lack thereof) does not increase or decrease their chances of being raped. I mean, you can be Victoria's Secret model or a wrinkled, 80-year-old woman and still be raped.

    It's 2019, and I think it's time that institutions, politicians and normal people realise that rape has nothing to do with sexual pleasure: rape is an act of domination, of humiliation, of overpowering someone else.

    So, no, sexual desire is not a necessary component of rape. Lust and sexual pleasure, sexual desire, have nothing to do with it. And people should just start realising that.

    Sputnik: What is the Italian public opinion's response to the overturning of the rape verdict?

    Giulia Ausani: People are outraged. Scores of protesters rallied outside Ancona's court doing a flash mob against the court's decision. They shouted, "Shame, shame". I think this reflects the general reaction of people everywhere in Italy.

    It's just insane. This verdict is just humiliating. It's wrong. The woman's lawyers said that it's not the only reason why the three judges decided to acquit the men of all charges. But it's still something that they took into consideration.

    READ MORE: Woman Kidnapped By Arab Migrant Gang in Italy Tells of Months-Long Sex Ordeal

    And not only that: in the documentation, they even added a photograph of the woman to prove her unattractiveness. They decided that the fact that one of the men had saved her number under the name of "the Viking" was more important than the fact that this woman had such genital trauma that she required stitches. This is just unbelievable.

    Sputnik: Only last week three eighteen-year-old men raped a girl inside a lift of the Circumvesuviana station near Naples. The parents of the culprits have reportedly applauded and shouted slogans to encourage their children. So considering also this instance, do Italians have an issue with handling rape cases and responding to them accordingly?

    Giulia Ausani: The case that you mentioned is very emblematic. It reflects not just the institutional problem with rape cases, but it just reflects rape culture in Italy. I mean, if the families of three alleged young rapists just decide to encourage them, to applaud them after they exit the police station where they have been interrogated, well, this really shows a big problem.

    Migrants in Padborg, Denmark
    © AP Photo / Mikkel Berg Pedesen/POLFOTO
    The thing is that we still live in a rape culture. So, yes, women in Italy are still being objectified. When you hear [about] some rape cases, the response from politicians, from institutions, and from normal people is just awful and sexist most of the time.

    In Italy, there is still the conviction that, if a woman dresses in a certain way, then she's asking for it. It's not always the case — I'm not saying that everybody in Italy reacts like that —, but there are still too many people who blame the victim.

    READ MORE: Migrant Drug Dealers Gang Rape and Kill Teenage Girl in Rome — Reports

    And this needs to change, because this is still linked to sexist beliefs. Italy's legal system is still deeply problematic. We have had several cases where judges recognised extenuating circumstances, because the rape victim was not a virgin anymore, or because she was wearing some specific underwear, or because she was sexually active. All these verdicts show a big problem in Italy's legal system and, in general, in Italian culture nowadays.

    Views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the speaker and do not necessarily reflect those of Sputnik.

    Related:

    Quran Teacher Arrested for Trying to Rape 8-Year-Old Girl in Pakistan - Reports
    Migrant Arrested in Finland in Connection With Rape of 2 Teen Girls - Reports
    'This B*tch Lyin': Chris Brown Will Reportedly Sue Rape Accuser for Defamation
    Tags:
    rape culture, rape, court, Italy
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik