01:14 GMT +316 October 2019
Listen Live
    Sings, reading U.S. Embassy in Jerusalem

    Merger of US Consulate, Embassy in Jerusalem Isn't 'the Last Straw' – Scholars

    © Sputnik / Amit Sha'al
    Get short URL
    0 22

    On 4 March 2019 the US merged its consulate dealing with Palestinian affairs and embassy in Jerusalem into one diplomatic mission. Speaking to Sputnik, Israeli researcher Mark Heller and American historian Daniel Pipes shared their views on how Washington's move may affect the Israeli-Palestinian peace process and Donald Trump's "peace plan".

    The Trump administration's decision to merge the US Consulate, which has long served as diplomatic mission for Palestinians, and the embassy in Jerusalem, has prompted criticism from Secretary General of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) Executive Committee Saeb Erekat, who called it "the last nail in the coffin of the US administration's role in peacemaking".

    "The only conceivable diplomatic motivation for subordinating the Jerusalem consulate [which is actually in West Jerusalem] to the US embassy is to add a bit more pressure on the Palestinians in advance of publication of Trump's peace plan, by signalling that there is now no direct formal bilateral American-Palestinian diplomatic channel at the Middle Eastern end [the PLO office in Washington was closed several months ago]," Mark Heller, principal research associate at the Tel Aviv-based Institute for National Security Studies (INSS), told Sputnik.

    The move came ahead of Donald Trump's announcement of his yet veiled Middle Eastern "peace deal". Previously, Washington moved its embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem which caused discontent among Palestinians and much of the international community.

    According to State Department spokesman Robert Palladino, the recent initiative "does not signal a change of US policy on Jerusalem, the West Bank, or the Gaza Strip".

    Heller noted that "the Palestinians themselves declared that they would cut off direct discussion about peace process after the US moved its Israel Embassy to Jerusalem and cut funding for the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA)" on 31 August 2018.

    According to the researcher, "the Palestinian Authority (PA) decided to forgo US assistance lest it open itself to US criminal charges because of its 'pay for slay' policy".

    Still, he believes that "a lot of this is symbolic and semantic".

    "The two sides can still communicate directly easily enough if they want to and there will still be a 'Palestinian Affairs Unit' to carry out the consulate-general's political functions".

    When asked whether the merge would affect the Israeli-Palestinian peace negotiations, Heller expressed doubts that the Trump administration's move could really upend the process "which has been dormant for a long time anyway but can be revived if everyone wants to do that".

    "If I had a ruble for every declaration by Saeb Erekat or Hanan Ashrawi that something or other is 'the last nail in the coffin of the peace process' or 'the straw that broke the camel's back,' I would be a rich man," the researcher remarked.

    For his part, Daniel Pipes, an American historian, writer, commentator, and president of the Middle East Forum, suggested that the US decision to merge the consulate with the embassy in Jerusalem had sent "a message of displeasure to the Palestinian Authority (PA) which has broken relations with the Trump administration".

    He believes that Palladino's statement that the move does not signal a change of US policy on Jerusalem, the West Bank, or the Gaza Strip is "credible" but it still signals Washington's "anger".

    Commenting on how the Trump administration's recent move will affect dialogue between the US and the Palestinians, Pipes presumed that "it might push the PA to re-enter talks with the US government".

    Likewise, the closure of the US representation for the PLO in Washington in September 2018, as well as the "cut-off of funds" were "intended to pressure Mahmoud Abbas to dialogue with Washington", according to the historian.

    The views and opinions expressed by the speakers do not necessarily reflect those of Sputnik.

    The views and opinions expressed in the article do not necessarily reflect those of Sputnik.


    FM Claims Pakistan Foiled 'Missile Attack Plotted by India, Israel'
    Ex-Envoy on US Merging Consulate With Embassy in Israel: 'Won't Make Any Change'
    Israel Attacks Gaza in Response to Launch of Balloons With Explosives - Army
    Israel Doesn't Have Political Leadership That Tries To Go Against Fear – Scholar
    UN Report Slams Israel for War Crimes in Gaza
    US Consulate General, Palestinians, US Embassy, Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), US Embassy in Jerusalem, Palestinian Authority, Donald Trump, Gaza Strip, Israel, United States, Middle East, Tel Aviv, West Bank, Jerusalem
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik