13:59 GMT +320 June 2019
Listen Live
    In this picture released by the Iranian Fars News Agency, asurface-to-surface missile is launched during the Iranian Revolutionary Guards maneuver in an undisclosed location in Iran, Tuesday, July 3, 2012

    US Threat to Pull Out of Iran Nuclear Deal Risks Opening Pandora's Box – Prof

    © AP Photo / Fars News Agency
    Get short URL

    Tehran has announced that it is ready for any eventuality as far as a US decision on the Iran nuclear deal is concerned. The announcement comes amid Boris Johnson's trip to the US to try to dissuade President Trump from pulling out of the agreement. Iran deal expert Dr. Moritz Pieper spoke to Sputnik about what to expect if Washington pulls out.

    Sputnik: What role could Secretary Boris Johnson play in dissuading President Trump from backing out of the Iran deal? Could he be more successful than Mr. Macron or Mrs. Merkel in this endeavor?

    Moritz Pieper: Boris Johnson of all people is unlikely to dissuade the Trump administration more than any other officials. Johnson, we have to remember, is a career politician who has proven before that he is willing to sacrifice policies to politics. [Emmanuel] Macron and [Angela] Merkel already met President Trump just recently. They publically said it wasn't their purpose to dissuade Trump to back out of the Iran deal, though we can assume that was public posturing. So of course Iran figured high on their agendas. 

    The Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) has successfully closed the lid on a very pressing nuclear proliferation crisis. If Trump does not recertify to Congress that Iran abides by this deal, it would constitute a violation of the deal. That's what it says in paragraph 26. It will be a violation of the deal and we can only hope that Congress would call out Trump for violating this agreement and resist imposing sanctions.

    Dawn breaks over the US Capitol building in Washington DC
    © AP Photo / J. Scott Applewhite
    Dawn breaks over the US Capitol building in Washington DC

    Sputnik: What options would Tehran have if the US were to pull out of the deal?

    Moritz Pieper: Iran would likely no longer see itself bound by its terms, because the United States would have violated it first. This would then lead to the collapse of the JCPOA because the Europeans, China and Russia cannot uphold it alone without Iran.

    So Iran has said it will not renegotiate the deal, and Europe should be careful not to try to appease the Trump administration by trying to renegotiate the deal and thereby violating it themselves.

    Trump's claims that the deal paves the way to an Iranian nuclear weapon in ten years – we remember the controversy around the sunset clauses – is based on a flawed analysis of the monitoring mechanisms that are in place. After those sunset clauses Iran will be treated as a normal Non-Proliferation Treaty signatory. We have to remember that Iran signed the NPT, and after these sunset clauses it will be treated like any other NPT member. This is a fundamental difference to, let's say North Korea, which has left the treaty. This is often disregarded in the discussion.

    A Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) was reached concerning Iran's nuclear program in Lausanne, Switzerland, June 2015.
    © AP Photo / Brendan Smialowski
    A Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) was reached concerning Iran's nuclear program in Lausanne, Switzerland, June 2015.

    Sputnik: In light of Israel's so-called secret nuclear files, what are your expectations regarding the decision that Mr. Trump is going to take when the deadline on the Iranian deal expires?

    Moritz Pieper: Undoing the legacy of your predecessor doesn't make for good policies. Trump's unrealistic demands that Congress and America's European partners fix the 2015 JCPOA is setting the United States up to violate the deal, as I've said before. 

    [As for Netanyahu], the so-called secret nuclear files have disclosed nothing new. This was Netanyahu's PR show. The alleged weaponization studies, as these are referred to by the International Atomic Energy Agency to describe Iran's past research into what's called a possible military dimension of its nuclear program, have been dealt with by the IAEA, [which is] the UN's nuclear watchdog.

    So this is nothing new. IAEA officials have confirmed that this is all material that they have seen. It has reconfirmed in ten reports that Iran is abiding by the terms of the 2005 JCPOA. Of course Trump sees himself as reconfirmed by these so-called secret nuclear files, but that's only because he doesn't know the specifics of the Iranian nuclear file, or he deliberately distorts the evidence.

    Israeli Prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks during a news conference at the Ministry of Defence in Tel Aviv, Israel April 30, 2018
    © REUTERS / Amir Cohen
    Israeli Prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks during a news conference at the Ministry of Defence in Tel Aviv, Israel April 30, 2018

    Sputnik: What position would a US pullout have with regard to its credibility to negotiate agreements?

    Moritz Pieper: If he fails to renew the sanctions waivers, this would be a clear violation of a multilaterally negotiated nuclear deal with Iran that has successfully managed to close the lid on a very urgent, very pressing international non-proliferation crisis. 

    Withholding these waivers would be dangerous; it would set up the United States to violate the deal, possibly risk a nuclear crisis emerging yet again, and tear up a nuclear agreement that has verifiably restricted Iran's nuclear activities.

    Dr. Moritz Pieper is a lecturer in international relations at the University of Salford in Manchester, whose PhD research focused on non-Western foreign policies toward the Iranian nuclear program. The views and opinions expressed by Dr. Pieper are those of the expert and do not necessarily reflect those of Sputnik.


    'We'll Resist': Iran Vows Unprecedented Consequences if US Exits Nuke Deal
    Trump Team Hired Agency to Discredit Obama's Iran Deal Negotiators - Reports
    Iran: Deal or No Deal?
    'Pandora's Box': Macron Warns US Exit From Iran Nuclear Deal Might Mean War
    expert analysis, nuclear deal, Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), Boris Johnson, Donald Trump, Benjamin Netanyahu, United Kingdom, Israel, United States, Iran
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik