04:35 GMT +321 May 2019
Listen Live
    People gather around the rubble of a hospital supported by Doctors Without Borders (MSF) near Maaret al-Numan, in Syria's northern province of Idlib, on February 15, 2016

    Report Accusing Russia of Bombing Syrian Hospitals 'Lacks Hard Data'

    © AFP 2019 / GHAITH OMRAN / AL-MAARRA TODAY
    Opinion
    Get short URL
    194

    A report by the US-based think tank accusing Russia of deliberately bombing hospitals during its anti-terrorists campaign in Syria has no hard proof to back up its questionable claims, US analysts told Sputnik.

    WASHINGTON (Sputnik) — A new report from the US-based think tank Atlantic Council accusing Russia of deliberately bombing hospitals during its anti-terrorists campaign in Syria has no hard data to back up its questionable claims and comes from an organization notorious for its propaganda against Russia, US analysts told Sputnik.

    "This publication from the Atlantic Council claims that it is based on ‘analysis of open source and social media intelligence (OSSMINT).’ This OSSMINT is a field completely invented by [report co-author Eliot] Higgins," Helena Cobban, a leading US expert on modern Syria and veteran Middle East correspondent, said.

    However, the so-called OSSMINT materials, presented on Tuesday, are a misleading mixture of unreliable sources using a methodology that has never been seriously accepted, Cobban pointed out.

    "OSSMINT consists of little more than capturing and aggregating claims made by anyone [that Higgins] chooses on social media; and over any sub-sample of a time period that he chooses to focus on. It's an echo chamber for whatever he chooses to echo," she noted.

    Higgins’ methodology in the report mixed reliable and verifiable information with unverifiable anecdotal claims of the most dubious accuracy, Cobban said.

    "It's worth underlining that by relying on both open source information and on what [Higgins] calls ‘social media intelligence,’ which is completely unverifiable, his method is completely unscientific," she pointed out.

    Serious reconnaissance photographic data about the pattern of Russia and US airstrikes over Syria was potentially available, yet the Atlantic Council report cited none whatsoever, Cobban observed.

    "Every government intelligence service with constant satellite surveillance over Syria… [including the United States, Russia and Israel] would be able to provide… solid numbers and figures about the location and authorship of the major military actions taken in Syria over the past 30 months. This report uses no such data," she said.

    Higgins had a strong history of partisanship in favor of the anti-government forces in Syria and has never had, nor had he claimed any formal training in military affairs or military science, Cobban noted.

    "In August 2013, [Higgins] and his blog became some of the main actors accusing the Syrian government of having used chemical weapons against the rebels near Damascus," she pointed out.

    Higgins’ false claim was widely spread and nearly catapulted the United States and United Kingdom into launching airstrikes against the Syrian government, Cobban recalled.

    However, that analysis was within days challenged and disproven by a team of real specialists in ballistics led by the veteran MIT military-tech specialist Theodore Postol, Cobban added.

    University of Illinois Professor of International Law Francis Boyle told Sputnik that the pattern of wild accusations using alleged evidence is based on no serious, accepted methodology reflecting the anti-Russian bias of the body that published it.

    "The Atlantic Council is a well-known anti-Russian, anti-Putin propaganda organization. Caveat lector [‘Let the reader beware’]" he said.

    Russia started its counter-terrorism operation in Syria in September 2015, at the request by Syrian President Bashar Assad. On March 15, Russia began withdrawing the largest bulk of its military from Syria after accomplishing its objectives.

    The Russian Defense Ministry issued daily reports on the results of its air campaign in Syria and released footage showing its air force striking targets.

    Related:

    Russia Helps Deliver Humanitarian Aid to Besieged Deir ez-Zor in Syria
    Russian Airstrikes Thwart Nusra Front Attacks Near Syria's Aleppo
    ‘Modus Operandi’ That US Has Sworn By in Syria and Elsewhere
    Tags:
    OSSMINT, claims, bombing, hospital, Syria, Russia
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik