07:26 GMT +328 March 2017
    US military soldiers march during the Veterans Day Parade in New York

    The Ghosts of War: Understanding the Shocking Suicide Rate of US Vets

    © AFP 2017/ Jewel Samad
    Get short URL

    Why are suicide rates among veterans higher than in the general US population, American author David Swanson asks, posing yet another question: why does the subject of war as a suicide-related motive never arise in official studies?

    The problem of high suicide rates among war veterans is widely discussed in the United States: the latest study has found that the suicide rate among recent veterans is 50 percent higher than non-military civilians.

    Incredible as it may seem, official reports brush aside the idea that war itself has anything to do with the problem, American activist and author David Swanson notes.

    "Remarkably, the subject of war, their role in war, their thoughts about the supposed justifications (or lack thereof) of a war, never come up," Swanson wrote in his article for Information Clearing House.

    The psychiatric studies and mass media reports are being focused on various "factors to blame" from "prior suicidality" to "poverty." However, they tell us virtually nothing, according to Swanson.

    "Perhaps their goal isn't to tell us something factual so much as to shift the conversation away from why war causes murder and suicide, to the question of what was wrong with these soldiers before they enlisted," the author remarked.

    The issue requires further investigation the American activist says, calling attention to the fact that violence and PTSD (posttraumatic stress disorder), which are closely connected with one another, are also higher among veterans than among non-veteran civilians.

    Furthermore, they are also higher for those who've taken part in combat operations than for those who've served in the military but never participated in combat. Swanson pointed out that they are "even higher for those who've been in even more combat," and usually higher for ground troops than for pilots.

    The crux of the matter is that going to war, which can be regarded as committing a state-sanctioned murder, increases criminal violence in the non-combat environment. And this fact shifts our attention directly to the problem of war, not to the problem of which fraction of returning troops to offer a "modicum of reorientation into nonviolent life," the activist noted.

    "But if you accept that war is necessary, and that most of the funding for it must go into profitable weaponry, then you're going to want to both identify which troops to help and shift the blame to those troops," Swanson underscored.

    Commenting on the problems of violence and suicide rates among US Army veterans, the authors of academic studies are inclined to focus on the troops' background, turning a blind eye to the fact that these servicemen had one important shared experience called "war."

    Some American researchers even go so far as to claim that this is a very simplistic approach to the problem to explain military suicide by "war-is-hell theory."

    "The impact of war on mental state is never discussed," Swanson stressed.

    What is then the real reason of the skyrocketing suicide rates among US combat veterans?

    "The answer is, I think, the same as the answer to the question of why the topic is so studiously avoided. The answer is summed up in the recent term: moral injury. You can't kill and face death and return unchanged to a world in which you are expected to refrain from all violence and relax," the US author underscored.

    "And returning to a world kept carefully oblivious to what you're going through, and eager to blame your demographic characteristics, must make it all the more difficult," he added.


    Europe Must Support Russia in Its Fight Against ISIL, No Ifs, Ands or Buts
    Russia's Strikes Shed Light on Inconvenient Truths of US' Anti-ISIL War
    Deployment of US Troops in Syria is a de Facto Act of War – Pat Buchanan
    veteran, PTSD, US troops, violence, military, suicide, war, US Army, United States
    Community standardsDiscussion
    Comment via FacebookComment via Sputnik
    • Сomment

    All comments

    • Mr. Blair M. Phillips
      "why does the subject of war as a suicide-related motive never arise in official studies?"

      Because the people that the American soldier kills has not done anything wrong to him or anyone else in his family but he follows Capitalism's orders(training). This...is the personal conflict. His own ethics and morality versus Capitalism's(no ethics or morals).
    • There is no such thing as an 'unwounded soldier'. Any one who goes to war with thoughts of glory, honour and valor have those thoughts changed once in battle. My great aunt was a head nurse in WW1. She suffered from shell shock and was institutionalized for the rest of her life. We don't have the death penalty in Canada and so we are not desensitized to atrocities seen in war. Many innocent people get killed in war. There is also the survivor guilt that plagues many as they have watched their fellow soldiers blown up.. War is hell and you are never the same after being involved in it.
    • ISIS is bringing up children who will not have an conscience when it comes to killing. They are brainwashing them while they are young...Children are brainwashed to join the Islamic State in a number of ways. After targeting a community for takeover, the Islamic State will typically kill the men, enslave the women and girl and take the young boys to be trained killers for the caliphate.

      In addition, Islamic State supporters from Arab countries as well as Europe have been encouraged to bring their young boys to Islamic State territory (a call which they have heeded) to receive training.

      Boys as young as five learn how to shoot and slaughter through a variety of methods -- lynching, beheading and suicide bombings.
    • Today we remember all who fought in the world wars. We were Brothers in Arms. May the fallen soldiers rest in peace and never be forgotten. www.youtube.com/watch?v=JC6oJURg6Pk
    • If you get the time to watch a programme which aired yesterday on the History Channel you might get an idea of why soldiers are damaged every time they kill another human being....www.history.ca/historys-days-of-remembrance/video/28-heroes/28-heroes/video.html?v=346292291536
    Show new comments (0)